Insights

The five case model: how to build a Green Book business case

HM Treasury’s five case model is the standard structure for public sector business cases in the UK, and it works just as well for any board that wants a decision it can defend. Here is what each case has to prove, how the SOC, OBC and FBC stages work, and why business cases get sent back.

By Christopher Fagan, Managing Partner, PEF Consulting Partners

£13bnlargest programme delivered
19 yrssenior systems delivery
5 continentsdelivered across
£25msaving on a single programme

Delivered for and alongside

ShellBPCapitaBaringaOfgemSmart DCCInsightsFlui TechnologiesExxonMobilVodafoneConstellation SoftwareDeloittePwCEYNational GridElexon

The five case model is HM Treasury’s framework for a business case. It tests a proposal five ways: the strategic case (is there a case for change?), the economic case (is it value for money?), the commercial case (is there a workable deal?), the financial case (is it affordable?) and the management case (can it be delivered?).

It comes from the HM Treasury Green Book, the government’s guidance on appraisal and evaluation, and from the Treasury’s supporting business case guidance for projects and programmes. Central government departments, arm’s length bodies, local authorities and the NHS use it, and it works just as well for a private board that wants a decision it can defend later.

Where the five case model comes from

The Green Book sets out how public bodies should appraise options and evaluate results. The Treasury’s business case guidance, often called Better Business Cases, turns that into a practical method: the five cases, a staged process for developing them and a standard way of narrowing options down. Together they set the expectations of anyone who will approve or scrutinise public spending, from a departmental investment committee to the Treasury itself.

A Green Book business case is not a different kind of document from a good business case. It is a good business case written to a structure reviewers know, so they can find what they need and test it quickly. Both the Green Book and the supporting guidance are updated from time to time, so check the current versions on gov.uk before you start.

The five cases explained

Strategic case

The strategic case makes the case for change. It sets out the current arrangements, what is wrong with them, how the proposal fits the organisation’s strategy and wider policy, and the spending objectives the investment must achieve. Spending objectives should be specific and measurable, because every option will be tested against them. This case also covers scope, the main benefits and risks, constraints and dependencies.

Economic case

The economic case shows that the preferred option offers the best value for money. It runs the options appraisal, from a long list to a short list to a preferred option, and compares the costs, benefits and risks of each shortlisted option, including an allowance for optimism bias. In Green Book terms, value is judged for society as a whole, not just for the organisation’s own budget.

Commercial case

The commercial case shows there is a workable deal. It covers what will be bought, the procurement route, how risk will be shared with suppliers, payment mechanisms, contract length and key terms, and any staff transfer implications. For public bodies it must reflect the rules in the Procurement Act 2023 and show how the organisation will secure social value through the tender.

Financial case

The financial case shows the proposal is affordable. Where the economic case looks at value to society in real terms, the financial case looks at the cash the organisation will actually spend, when, and from which budget, including the effect on capital and revenue budgets and any funding gap. If the money is not confirmed, the financial case should say so plainly.

Management case

The management case shows the proposal can be delivered. It names the senior responsible owner and sets out governance, the delivery plan, risk management, change management, assurance, and how benefits will be tracked and evaluated after delivery. A benefits realisation plan belongs here, with a named owner for each benefit.

Strategic outline case, outline business case and full business case

Business cases for significant spending are usually built in three stages. Each stage adds depth to all five cases, rather than completing one case at a time.

StageMain questionWhat it needs to showWhat approval allows
Strategic outline case (SOC)Is there a case for change, and what is the preferred way forward?Strategic context, spending objectives, the long list and how it was narrowed, a preferred way forward and indicative costs.Further work on a short list of options.
Outline business case (OBC)Which option offers the best value for money, and can we afford and deliver it?Full appraisal of the short list, the preferred option, the proposed deal and procurement route, affordability and delivery arrangements.Going to market to procure the preferred option.
Full business case (FBC)Is the negotiated deal still the best value, and are we ready to commit?The procurement outcome, final costs and contract terms, confirmed funding, and detailed plans for delivery, benefits and assurance.Signing the contract and committing the money.

Programmes follow a similar path through a strategic outline programme and a programme business case, with individual projects then running their own cases. Smaller, lower risk proposals often use a single shorter business case, depending on the delegations your organisation works to.

Options appraisal: from long list to short list

Options appraisal is where most business cases are won or lost. Reviewers want to see that you considered a genuine range of ways to meet the spending objectives, not one preferred answer surrounded by weaker alternatives built to lose.

The Treasury guidance uses an options framework to build the long list, working through choices on scope (what is covered), solution (how it is done), delivery (who does it), implementation (when and in what order) and funding (how it is paid for). Each choice is tested against the spending objectives and a set of critical success factors. In the guidance these are usually framed as strategic fit and business needs, potential value for money, supplier capacity and capability, potential affordability and potential achievability.

Options that fail are discounted, with the reason recorded. The short list normally keeps business as usual as a benchmark, a realistic do minimum option, the preferred way forward and at least one alternative. The table shows a hypothetical example for a council replacing its finance system.

OptionMeets spending objectivesStrategic fitValue for moneySupplier capacityAffordabilityAchievabilityDecision
1. Business as usual: keep the current system on premisesNoNoNoPartlyYesYesCarry forward as the benchmark
2. Do minimum: upgrade to the supplier’s latest supported versionPartlyPartlyPartlyYesYesYesCarry forward
3. Cloud finance system bought through an existing frameworkYesYesYesYesPartlyYesCarry forward as the preferred way forward
4. Shared finance service with neighbouring councilsYesYesYesPartlyYesPartlyCarry forward as an alternative
5. Bespoke system built in housePartlyPartlyNoNoNoNoDiscount on cost, skills and delivery risk

Two points are worth noticing. Options 3 and 4 are close, which is exactly why both go through to full appraisal rather than one being picked now. And the preferred way forward is a type of solution, not a product: the choice of supplier comes later, through procurement, which is why the outline business case has to set out the procurement route clearly before anyone goes to market.

Why business cases get sent back

Business cases are rarely rejected outright. More often they come back with questions that cost weeks, and the same problems come up again and again.

  • A solution looking for a problem. The strategic case describes a system or a supplier rather than a need, so the options appraisal looks like a formality.
  • Vague spending objectives. If the objectives cannot be measured, options cannot be tested against them.
  • A long list built to fail. Alternatives that were never realistic tell the reviewer the decision was made before the appraisal.
  • Benefits without baselines. Claimed improvements with no measure of today’s position, or cash releasing and non cash releasing benefits mixed together.
  • Optimism. No allowance for optimism bias, and risks listed but not costed.
  • Missing whole life costs. Licences, support, internal staff time, data migration, training, parallel running and decommissioning left out.
  • A commercial case that does not match the market. A procurement route or contract structure that suppliers will not bid for.
  • Assumed funding. A financial case that relies on money nobody has confirmed.
  • A thin management case. No named senior responsible owner, no realistic plan and no owner for each benefit.
  • Cases that do not reconcile. Different figures in the economic and financial cases with no explanation of why.

Using the five case model for technology and transformation investments

Technology and transformation proposals are where the five case model is most often stretched, because the benefits are real but hard to pin down and the costs are easy to underestimate. A few habits make these cases far stronger.

  • Be honest about benefits. Time saved is usually a non cash releasing benefit unless posts or contracts actually go. Treasury guidance expects the two to be kept apart, and reviewers check.
  • Cost the transition, not just the system. Data migration, backfill for staff working on the programme, testing, training, parallel running and a period of hypercare can easily outweigh the licence cost.
  • Watch the capital and revenue split. Moving from an owned system to a subscription service usually shifts spend from capital to revenue. In the public sector, where the two budgets are controlled separately, that can change which option is affordable.
  • Write the exit into the commercial case. Data ownership, exit support and price increases at renewal matter more for software services than for most purchases.
  • Treat adoption as part of deliverability. A system that goes live but is not used delivers none of the benefits in the economic case, so change management belongs in the management case.

Our guide to the ERP business case covers the finance system version of this in more detail, and our business case template follows the same five part structure. The strategic case is also easier to write once you have done a proper gap analysis of where you are against where you need to be.

Where the five case model meets delivery

A business case is a promise about delivery, and the management and financial cases are where that promise gets tested. As Project Director, Christopher Fagan led the £9bn Energy Bills Support Scheme, working for Ofgem, BEIS and HMRC, accountable for implementation from start to finish and for making sure public money reached households rather than leaking away along the route. On a scheme like that, the questions a management case asks about control, accountability and evidence stop being paperwork and become the daily job, as our piece on running a public support scheme explains.

The commercial case gets the same treatment. On the National Grid separation, Christopher ran every software procurement from business case to live service, the Oracle to SAP S/4HANA switch among them. PEF is independent, with no reseller agreements or commissions from any software vendor, so when we help build an options appraisal the options are judged on their merits.

Our procurement consultancy and our work across government and the public sector bring that discipline to business cases at every stage, from the first strategic outline case to the signed contract. We stay for delivery too, because a business case is only as good as what happens after approval.

Common questions

What are the five cases in the five case model?

The five cases are strategic, economic, commercial, financial and management. The strategic case shows the case for change, the economic case shows value for money through an options appraisal, the commercial case shows a workable deal, the financial case shows affordability, and the management case shows the proposal can be delivered, with governance, plans, risk management and benefits tracking.

What is the difference between an SOC, OBC and FBC?

They are the three stages of a Green Book business case. The strategic outline case confirms the case for change and a preferred way forward from a long list. The outline business case appraises the short list and identifies the preferred option and procurement route. The full business case follows procurement and confirms the final deal, costs and delivery plans before commitment.

What is an options appraisal?

An options appraisal is a structured comparison of different ways to meet a set of objectives. In a Green Book business case it starts with a long list built across choices of scope, solution, delivery, implementation and funding, filters that list against spending objectives and critical success factors, then compares the costs, benefits and risks of the short list to find the preferred option.

What are critical success factors in a business case?

Critical success factors are the attributes any successful option must have, used alongside the spending objectives to filter the long list. HM Treasury guidance usually frames them as strategic fit and business needs, potential value for money, supplier capacity and capability, potential affordability and potential achievability. Tailor each one to the proposal so it actually separates strong options from weak ones.

Can the five case model be used outside government?

Yes. Although it was written for public spending, the five case model suits any investment decision that has to be defended. A private company, regulated business or charity can use the same structure to show the case for change, compare options fairly, confirm the deal, prove affordability and show the proposal can be delivered. Anyone who has worked with the public sector will recognise it.

Related reading: Business case template, How to build an ERP business case, Benefits realisation plan template, Procurement Act 2023 thresholds and Government and public sector.

Building a business case that has to survive scrutiny?

We help public bodies and private boards build business cases that hold up, from the strategic outline case through procurement to the full business case, and then help deliver what the case promised. Tell us what you are proposing and where it is stuck.

Book a confidential conversation

Sources: HM Treasury, The Green Book: appraisal and evaluation in central government, https://www.gov.uk/government/publications/the-green-book-appraisal-and-evaluation-in-central-government; HM Treasury, Guide to developing the project business case (Better Business Cases), 2018; HM Treasury, Guide to developing the programme business case (Better Business Cases), 2018

PEF TRACK RECORD£13bnLargestprogramme led5Continentsdelivered across19 yrsSystems delivery£25mLargestsingle saving
CF

Written by Christopher Fagan

Managing Partner, PEF Consulting Partners

Christopher has led systems and transformation delivery for 19 years, including the National Grid separation, the £9bn Energy Bills Support Scheme and the BP Pulse EV charging rollout.