Turnaround

Business turnaround strategy: the stages that actually work

A business turnaround strategy is the order in which you fix a struggling business: face the facts, protect cash, decide what the business should be, change how it runs, and prove it is working. This is a practical guide to each stage and what goes in the plan.

By Christopher Fagan, Managing Partner, PEF Consulting Partners

£13bnlargest programme delivered
£25msaving on the BP Pulse rollout
£160m+billing imbalance recovered
5 continentsdelivered across

Delivered for and alongside

ShellBPCapitaBaringaOfgemSmart DCCInsightsFlui TechnologiesExxonMobilVodafoneConstellation SoftwareDeloittePwCEYNational GridElexon

Face the facts before you write the plan

Every business turnaround strategy starts with an honest diagnosis, and that is the stage most often rushed. Management teams in trouble tend to know the headline problem, such as falling margin or rising debt, but not the causes underneath it.

The questions to answer in the first few weeks are simple to ask and hard to answer well:

  • Where exactly does the business make money and lose it, by customer, product, channel and site?
  • How long does cash take to come in from an order, and how quickly does it go out?
  • Have the forecasts the board has been seeing been reliable? If not, why not?
  • Is the core business still viable once the loss making parts are removed?
  • Which problems are caused inside the business, and which come from the market?

The answers should be evidenced, not argued. That usually means pulling transaction data out of the ledger and systems and rebuilding profit by line, rather than relying on management accounts that average everything together. A structured root cause analysis helps separate symptoms from causes.

My view, Christopher Fagan: in my experience the diagnosis almost always finds that a small number of customers, products or contracts are doing most of the damage, and that people inside the business already suspected it. What was missing was the evidence and the permission to act. If your diagnosis does not produce a short list of uncomfortable facts, it probably has not gone deep enough.

Protect cash so you have time to fix anything

A turnaround runs on time, and time is bought with cash. While the diagnosis is under way, the second stage starts in parallel: taking control of cash.

In practice that means:

  • A weekly 13 week cash flow forecast, owned by one person and reviewed every week.
  • Central approval of all discretionary spend, recruitment and new commitments for a defined period.
  • A focused push on overdue debtors, starting with the largest balances.
  • A review of stock, work in progress and anything else that ties up cash without earning it.
  • Early, honest conversations with the bank and key suppliers. They respond far better to being told early than to finding out.

Stabilisation is not the turnaround. Delaying supplier payments or squeezing customers can only be done once, and it damages relationships you will need later. The aim is to create a stable platform and a few months of visibility so the real changes can be made properly.

My view: the most common mistake I see at this stage is cutting things that are easy to cut rather than things that matter. Training budgets and small contracts go first because nobody argues, while a loss making customer contract carries on because the relationship is senior. Cash control should follow the diagnosis, not the path of least resistance.

Decide what business you are going to be

Once the facts are known and cash is under control, the leadership team has to make the strategic decisions. This is the heart of any plan for how to turn around a loss making business, and it is where many plans stay vague.

For each customer group, product line, contract and site, there are only a few real choices:

  • Keep it, because it makes money and fits the future business.
  • Fix it, because it could make money with changes to price, cost or the way it is delivered.
  • Reprice it, because the work is fine but the terms are wrong.
  • Exit it, because it cannot be made to pay or does not fit.

Writing these decisions down, line by line, makes the strategy concrete. It also shows what the business will look like afterwards: its size, its customers, its margin and the cost base it can afford. That smaller, clearer business is what the rest of the plan builds towards.

Exits need care. Contracts have notice periods and obligations, staff have rights, and some customers will be lost on purpose. Get legal advice where it is needed, and plan the communication before you act. For businesses with a private equity owner, these choices should be tested with the operating partner, and a proper value creation plan is often the right vehicle for them.

My view: exiting is the decision boards find hardest and most often delay. A business that keeps everything it has rarely turns around.

Change how the business runs, not just what it costs

Cost cutting on its own does not turn a business around. If the processes, systems and structure that created the cost stay the same, the cost comes back within a year or two. The fourth stage changes how the business actually works.

Operating model and processes

Redesign the main flows, such as quoting, ordering, fulfilment, invoicing and purchasing, to remove duplication and rework. Set clear decision rights so the leadership team is not approving everything. Our guide to what an operating model is sets out the parts that need to fit together.

Systems, data and reporting

Decide quickly whether struggling systems should be fixed, simplified or replaced. A turnaround is rarely the moment for a large new system, but it is often the moment to stop paying for one that does not work. The board needs a small set of weekly numbers it trusts: cash, margin by line, debtor days, order book and delivery against the plan.

Structure and leadership

Make the structure fit the smaller, clearer business. Fill critical gaps, which may mean interim leaders for a period, and be clear about who owns each part of the plan.

My view: at PEF we have supported turnarounds in hedge funds and private equity portfolio companies, fixing operating models and processes, recovering cost and cash, fixing or replacing systems, data and reporting, and providing interim leadership. The lasting gains came from the operating changes, not the cuts.

What goes into a business turnaround plan

A business turnaround plan turns the strategy into actions people can deliver. It does not need to be long. It does need to be specific. A good plan contains:

  1. The case for change. A short, evidenced summary of what the diagnosis found and why the business has to change.
  2. The target business. What the business will look like in twelve months: customers, products, sites, headcount, margin and cash.
  3. The decisions. The keep, fix, reprice and exit choices, line by line.
  4. The actions. Each with an owner, a start and end date, a cost to deliver and the cash or margin it is expected to deliver.
  5. The cash bridge. How the actions move the business from today’s cash position to the target, week by week for the first quarter and monthly after that.
  6. Risks and dependencies. What could stop each action, and what you will do if it happens.
  7. Governance. Who meets, how often, what they see and what they decide.

Share the plan with the people who need to back it: the board, the owners, the lenders and the senior team. Each will want to see that the numbers in the plan reconcile to the cash forecast and the management accounts.

My view: a plan with forty actions is a wish list. Most of the value in the turnarounds I have seen came from fewer than ten actions. Put those at the top, give them the best people, and track them every week.

Prove it is working, and know when to change course

The last stage is delivery, measured honestly. A turnaround plan needs a weekly rhythm: a short meeting, the same small set of numbers, progress on the main actions, and decisions on anything that is off track.

The signs that a business turnaround strategy is working:

  • The cash forecast is accurate in the near weeks, and the low point is moving up rather than down.
  • Gross margin is improving on the lines the plan said it would.
  • The main actions are landing on time, or the slips are known and explained.
  • Lenders and owners are asking fewer questions because the reporting answers them.
  • Decisions are being made by the people closest to the work, not escalated.

Just as important is knowing when the plan is not working. If cash keeps falling despite the actions, or the core business turns out not to be viable, the directors need to hear that early. At that point the options may include a financial restructuring or a formal process, which is a matter for licensed insolvency practitioners and lawyers. Our restructuring advisory page explains how operational work fits alongside them.

Behind our business turnaround consulting is a suite of consultants who have led and analysed decisions and delivery before, during and after major programmes.

My view: the turnarounds that succeed are the ones where the leadership team stops defending the past and starts reporting the truth every week. The method matters, but honesty matters more.

Related reading: Business turnaround consulting, The 13 week cash flow forecast, Restructuring advisory, Root cause analysis, Portfolio company turnaround.

Common questions

What is a business turnaround strategy?

A business turnaround strategy is the plan for bringing an underperforming or loss making business back to sustainable profit and cash generation. It usually moves through stages: an evidenced diagnosis, cash stabilisation, decisions about which parts of the business to keep, fix, reprice or exit, changes to how the business runs, and disciplined weekly delivery against a written plan.

What are the main business turnaround strategies?

The common strategies are cash conservation, cost reduction, repricing, exiting loss making customers, products or sites, focusing on the core business, operational improvement to processes and systems, and changes to leadership. Most successful turnarounds use several together, in the right order: cash first, then the strategic choices, then lasting changes to how the business runs. Financial restructuring of debt can sit alongside these but is led by specialist advisers.

How do you turn around a loss making business?

Start by finding out exactly where the losses come from, by customer, product and site, using transaction data rather than averages. Protect cash with a weekly forecast and tight spend control. Then decide what to keep, fix, reprice or exit, change the processes and systems that drive cost, and track a short list of actions every week. Be honest early if the core business is not viable.

How long does a business turnaround plan take?

Diagnosis and cash stabilisation typically take the first few weeks. The main strategic and operational changes usually run over several months, and the full turnaround often takes a year or more before the business is reliably profitable and cash generative. The plan should set out milestones for the first quarter in detail so the board and lenders can see early whether it is on track.

When should a business bring in turnaround help?

Earlier than most do. Good triggers are margin falling for several months, cash getting tighter despite steady sales, forecasts that keep missing, lenders asking harder questions, or a covenant getting close. Outside help is most valuable while there is still enough cash and time to make choices. Waiting until the position is critical narrows the options considerably.

Does your turnaround plan have fewer than ten actions that really matter? If you are not sure, talk to us about a short diagnosis that tells you where to start.

Book a confidential conversation

PEF TRACK RECORD£13bnLargestprogramme led5Continentsdelivered across19 yrsSystems delivery£25mLargestsingle saving

Consultancy from PEF

Independent, client side support when the business is off plan or changing shape: business turnaround, restructuring advisory, chief transformation officer, centres of excellence, shared services and gbs, asset management, hedge funds, oil and gas, portfolio company turnaround. For our fees see pricing.

CF

Written by Christopher Fagan

Managing Partner, PEF Consulting Partners

Christopher has led systems and transformation delivery for 19 years, including the National Grid separation, the £9bn Energy Bills Support Scheme and the BP Pulse EV charging rollout.