Insights

Value chain analysis: Porter’s model with an energy retail example

Value chain analysis breaks a business into the activities that create value, so you can see where cost and advantage really come from. Here is how Porter’s model works, how to apply it and what it looks like for an energy retailer.

By Christopher Fagan, Managing Partner, PEF Consulting Partners

£13bnlargest programme delivered
19 yrssenior systems delivery
5 continentsdelivered across
£25msaving on a single programme

Delivered for and alongside

ShellBPCapitaBaringaOfgemSmart DCCInsightsFlui TechnologiesExxonMobilVodafoneConstellation SoftwareDeloittePwCEYNational GridElexon

Value chain analysis is a method for breaking a business into the activities it performs to deliver its product or service, then asking which of them create value for customers, which drive cost and how they connect. Michael Porter introduced the model in 1985 to explain where competitive advantage actually comes from.

For a board or executive team, its appeal is that it replaces broad claims such as ‘we compete on service’ with something testable: which activities deliver that service, what they cost and whether they beat a competitor’s. That makes it a practical bridge between strategy and the operating model.

What value chain analysis is for

The value chain treats a business as a set of activities rather than a set of departments or products. Every activity adds cost, and some also add something customers will pay for or something that sets the business apart. The gap between what customers pay and the cost of all the activities is the margin, which is why Porter drew margin at the end of the chain.

Used properly, the analysis answers practical questions. Where is our cost out of line? Which activities justify a price premium, and which should we simplify, automate or outsource? Where do weak links between activities, such as sales promising what operations cannot deliver, destroy value that each activity creates on its own?

Where Porter’s value chain came from

Porter set out the model in Competitive Advantage: Creating and Sustaining Superior Performance, published in 1985, following his earlier work on industry structure and the five forces. His argument was that advantage cannot be understood by looking at a firm as a whole. It comes from the many separate activities a firm performs, and from how well it performs and connects them.

He also placed each firm’s chain inside a wider value system that links the value chains of its suppliers, its channels and its customers. That wider view matters more now than it did then, because so much of a modern business’s cost and risk sits with third parties.

Primary activities in the value chain model

Porter split activities into two groups. Primary activities are the ones directly involved in creating the product or service and getting it to the customer.

  • Inbound logistics: receiving, storing and managing the inputs.
  • Operations: turning those inputs into the finished product or service.
  • Outbound logistics: getting the product to the customer, including order processing and delivery.
  • Marketing and sales: making customers aware of the product and persuading them to buy it, including pricing and channels.
  • Service: everything that maintains or adds to the product’s value after the sale, such as installation, repairs, support and complaints handling.

Support activities

Support activities make the primary activities possible, and most of them run across the whole chain.

  • Firm infrastructure: general management, finance, planning, legal and regulatory affairs, quality management.
  • Human resource management: recruiting, training, rewarding and keeping people.
  • Technology development: the know how, systems and process technology behind every activity, not just research and development.
  • Procurement: buying the inputs used anywhere in the chain, from raw materials to software and professional services.

Porter drew the categories with manufacturing in mind. In a service or utility business the labels need translating, and deciding where an activity belongs is part of the analysis rather than an administrative chore.

How to do a value chain analysis in six steps

  1. Define the business unit. Analyse one business with one strategy at a time. A group with a retail arm and a networks arm has two value chains, not one.
  2. Map the activities. List the primary and support activities in your own terms, at a level a manager would recognise. Ten to twenty activities is usually enough.
  3. Attach cost and effort. Allocate operating cost, headcount and assets to each activity. Rough figures are fine at first, because the aim is to see proportions, not to build a costing model.
  4. Identify the drivers. For each activity, ask what makes it cost more or less, such as volume, complexity, error rates or technology, and what makes customers value it, such as speed, accuracy or reliability.
  5. Look at the linkages. Porter stressed that advantage often lies in how activities connect: a sales process that feeds cleaner data into billing, or a purchasing decision that cuts service calls.
  6. Compare and decide. Benchmark against competitors or your own targets, then decide what to invest in, fix, simplify, automate or outsource.

Step four is where most of the insight sits. Two activities can cost the same and play completely different roles: one is a source of advantage worth protecting, while the other is a cost to drive down as far as it will go.

Value chain analysis example: a hypothetical energy retailer

The example below is invented to show the method. It describes a hypothetical mid sized UK energy retailer supplying homes and small businesses. Inbound logistics has been translated as wholesale purchasing, because the energy itself is the retailer’s main input, and outbound logistics as billing and payments, because the bill is how the product reaches the customer.

ActivityWhat it covers hereMain driverHypothetical finding
Primary: wholesale purchasingBuying energy ahead and close to delivery, managing imbalance exposureHedging policy, demand forecast accuracyLargest cost line; forecast errors add imbalance charges
Primary: onboarding and metering operationsSwitching customers in, registration, meter data, settlementData quality, industry process automationFailed switches and missing reads handled by hand
Primary: billing and paymentsCalculating and issuing bills, taking payments, collectionsBill accuracy, debt levelsBilling exceptions are the single biggest cause of contact
Primary: marketing and salesTariff design, comparison and broker channels, renewalsAcquisition cost, customer retentionAcquisition cost high against expected customer lifetime
Primary: customer serviceContact centre, digital self service, complaints, support for customers in vulnerable circumstancesContact volume and its causesHighest controllable cost, most of it caused upstream
Support: firm infrastructureFinance, risk, licence compliance, regulatory reportingPace of regulatory changeFixed cost rising with each new obligation
Support: human resourcesRecruiting, training and keeping contact centre staffStaff turnoverHigh turnover lowers first contact resolution
Support: technologyBilling platform, CRM, data and automationPlatform fit, data qualityLegacy platform limits self service and automation
Support: procurementMetering agents, IT suppliers and other third partiesContract terms, supplier performanceMany small contracts with weak performance measures

Laid out like this, the pattern in the hypothetical retailer is clear. Customer service is the highest controllable cost, but most of that cost is created upstream, in billing and in onboarding data. Cutting contact centre headcount would attack the symptom, while fixing bill accuracy would reduce contacts, complaints and bad debt together. That is a linkage, and finding linkages is what the method is for.

The analysis also separates what must be done well from what wins customers. Wholesale purchasing is the largest cost and the biggest risk, so it has to be run tightly, but done well it mostly protects margin rather than attracting customers. Tariff design and service quality are where this retailer can stand apart, so a sensible strategy invests in those and drives the rest towards efficient parity, often through better use of the billing platform rather than more people.

Our cost to serve work takes findings like these and puts real numbers on them, by customer segment and by channel.

When it works and where it falls short

The method works best for businesses with a recognisable flow from inputs to customers: manufacturers, distributors, retailers, utilities and many service operations. It is useful when cost is under pressure, when a strategy needs translating into an operating model, when deciding what to outsource, and when assessing a business before an acquisition.

It fits less well where the business is not really a chain. Professional services firms solve problems for clients, and platforms connect buyers and sellers; Charles Stabell and Øystein Fjeldstad argued in 1998 that these are better described as value shops and value networks. The underlying questions still apply, but forcing a platform business into Porter’s nine boxes produces a neat diagram and very little insight.

One common confusion is worth clearing up. In sustainability reporting, ‘value chain’ is used more loosely to mean everyone upstream and downstream of the business, which is why Scope 3 emissions are often called value chain emissions. That is closer to Porter’s value system and is a different exercise, covered in our guide to Scope 1, 2 and 3 emissions.

Common mistakes

  • Mapping departments instead of activities. The finance department is not an activity. Billing, credit control and financial reporting are.
  • Stopping at the diagram. A labelled chart with no costs, drivers or comparison is a description, not an analysis.
  • Ignoring linkages. Looking at each activity in isolation misses the most valuable findings, which usually sit between activities.
  • Treating support activities as overhead. Technology and procurement choices often set the cost of every primary activity.
  • No customer evidence. Value is defined by what customers will pay for, not by what the business is proud of, so test assumptions against customer data.
  • Doing it once. The chain shifts when the market, the technology or the regulation changes. Revisit it with each major strategy review.

How it connects to strategy and operating model work

The analysis sits between strategy and execution. It takes a strategic choice, such as competing on service or on cost, and shows which activities have to change to support it. Those activities then become the building blocks of the operating model and of the capability maps used in business architecture.

It pairs well with an organisational lens. The value chain tells you what the business must do well, and the McKinsey 7S model tests whether its structure, systems, skills and culture are set up to do it. For a single process inside the chain, a SIPOC diagram is the natural next level of detail.

PEF helps leadership teams run this analysis on their own data and then carry the findings into delivery, through our strategy consulting and operational excellence work. We work alongside your people to design and build the changes, rather than leaving a slide deck behind. The energy retail example is close to home: Christopher Fagan has led Kraken platform migrations for UK utilities, one of them delivered 65 days early and on budget.

Common questions

What is value chain analysis?

Value chain analysis is a method for breaking a business down into the activities it performs to deliver its product or service. Each activity is examined for what it costs, what drives that cost and what value it creates for customers. The aim is to find where competitive advantage comes from, where cost is out of line and how the links between activities can be improved.

What are the primary activities in Porter’s value chain?

Porter’s model has five primary activities: inbound logistics, operations, outbound logistics, marketing and sales, and service. Together they cover receiving inputs, turning them into a product or service, getting it to the customer, persuading customers to buy, and supporting them after the sale. In service businesses the labels are usually translated, for example billing in place of outbound logistics.

What are support activities in the value chain?

Support activities are the four functions that make the primary activities possible: firm infrastructure, human resource management, technology development and procurement. Firm infrastructure covers management, finance, legal and regulatory work. Technology development covers systems and know how across the business, not just research. Support activities often set the cost of every primary activity, so they deserve as much attention.

How do you do a value chain analysis?

Define the business unit, then list its primary and support activities in your own terms. Attach cost, people and assets to each, and identify what drives cost and what drives customer value. Look closely at the links between activities, where many of the best findings sit. Finally, compare against competitors or targets and decide what to invest in, fix, automate or outsource.

What is the difference between a value chain and a supply chain?

A supply chain is the flow of goods, materials and information from suppliers through to the customer, and it is mostly about logistics and planning. A value chain is broader. It covers every activity a business performs, including marketing, service, technology and management, and asks which of them create value and advantage. The supply chain is one part of the picture a value chain gives you.

Related reading: McKinsey 7S model, What is an operating model?, Cost to serve analysis and Strategy consulting.

Want to know where your margin really comes from?

We can work through your value chain with your leadership team, using your own cost and customer data, and turn what it shows into a plan you can deliver.

Book a confidential conversation

Sources: Porter, M. E., Competitive Advantage: Creating and Sustaining Superior Performance, 1985; Stabell, C. B. and Fjeldstad, Ø. D., Configuring Value for Competitive Advantage: On Chains, Shops, and Networks, Strategic Management Journal, 1998

PEF TRACK RECORD£13bnLargestprogramme led5Continentsdelivered across19 yrsSystems delivery£25mLargestsingle saving
CF

Written by Christopher Fagan

Managing Partner, PEF Consulting Partners

Christopher has led systems and transformation delivery for 19 years, including the National Grid separation, the £9bn Energy Bills Support Scheme and the BP Pulse EV charging rollout.