Insights

The Kraljic matrix explained: quadrants, strategies and a worked example

Peter Kraljic’s portfolio model is still one of the quickest ways to decide where procurement effort should go. This guide shows how to score your spend, what each quadrant needs and how it plays out on a hypothetical technology and services portfolio.

By Christopher Fagan, Managing Partner, PEF Consulting Partners

£13bnlargest programme delivered
19 yrssenior systems delivery
5 continentsdelivered across
£25msaving on a single programme

Delivered for and alongside

ShellBPCapitaBaringaOfgemSmart DCCInsightsFlui TechnologiesExxonMobilVodafoneConstellation SoftwareDeloittePwCEYNational GridElexon

The Kraljic matrix is a two by two tool that sorts everything an organisation buys by two measures: profit impact, meaning how much an item affects cost, quality or revenue, and supply risk, meaning how hard it is to secure. Each of the four resulting quadrants calls for a different purchasing strategy and a different kind of supplier relationship.

Its value is focus. No procurement team can give every contract the same attention, and the matrix gives a defensible reason to concentrate on a handful of critical categories while running the rest efficiently. It also gives finance, operations and procurement a shared language for why one supplier gets a partnership and another gets a reverse auction.

Where the Kraljic model comes from

Peter Kraljic set out the model in a 1983 Harvard Business Review article, Purchasing Must Become Supply Management. He was writing for companies facing raw material shortages, political turbulence in supply markets and fast technological change, and his argument was that buying could no longer be treated as an administrative task. Supply had become a strategic risk and needed to be managed as one.

The approach is often called the Kraljic portfolio purchasing model, because it treats purchases the way an investor treats a portfolio: different holdings need different handling. Kraljic described four stages.

  1. Classification. Sort purchases by profit impact and supply risk.
  2. Market analysis. Weigh your bargaining power against the power of suppliers in each market.
  3. Strategic positioning. For the strategic items, decide whether to exploit your strength, balance the relationship or diversify away from a dominant supplier.
  4. Action planning. Turn each position into a sourcing plan with owners and dates.

In practice many teams stop after the first stage and use only the grid. The later stages are where much of the value sits, and they are built into the step by step method below.

The four quadrants: strategic, leverage, bottleneck and non critical items

The grid puts profit impact on one axis and supply risk on the other. That produces four groups, each with its own logic.

  • Strategic items (high profit impact, high supply risk). Purchases that matter a great deal and come from a small number of capable suppliers. The aim is a long term partnership with shared plans, close governance and a contingency if it fails.
  • Leverage items (high profit impact, low supply risk). Significant spend in a competitive market. The aim is to use your buying power: aggregate volume, run competitive tenders and switch suppliers when price or service justifies it.
  • Bottleneck items (low profit impact, high supply risk). Small purchases that can still stop the operation, because only one or two suppliers can provide them. The aim is security of supply: buffer stock where it applies, backup suppliers, longer contracts and, where possible, a change of specification so the item stops being scarce.
  • Non critical items (low profit impact, low supply risk). Routine purchases in open markets. The aim is efficiency: standardise, consolidate suppliers, use simple buying channels and keep the cost of the process below the value of the item.

The quadrants describe categories of spend, not the worth of a supplier as a business. The same supplier can be non critical for one organisation and strategic for another.

Profit impact and supply risk: scoring the two axes

The matrix is only as good as the scoring behind it. Agree the criteria with finance, operations and budget holders before anyone plots a point, and score each category on a simple scale such as 1 to 5.

Profit impact asks how much the category affects the results of the business. Useful criteria include:

  • Annual spend and its share of the total cost base.
  • Effect on the quality, safety or reliability of what you deliver to customers.
  • Effect on revenue, for example where the item forms part of a product or service you sell.
  • Cost of failure, including regulatory penalties and damage to reputation.

Supply risk asks how hard the category is to secure on acceptable terms. Useful criteria include:

  • The number of capable suppliers and how concentrated the market is.
  • The cost and lead time of switching supplier.
  • Availability of substitutes, or room to change the specification.
  • Exposure to shortages, geopolitical events or regulatory change.
  • Dependence on specialist skills, intellectual property or proprietary technology.

Weight the criteria if some matter more to you, and write down the reason behind each score. The written reasoning is what lets you defend the result and revisit it a year later.

How to build a Kraljic matrix step by step

  1. Start with the spend data. Extract twelve months of accounts payable and purchase order data, clean the supplier names and classify the spend into categories.
  2. Group by supply market. Define categories by the market that supplies them, not the department that buys them. Cloud hosting bought by three departments is one category.
  3. Agree the criteria and weights. Settle the scoring rules with stakeholders first, so the debate is about the rules rather than about anyone’s favourite supplier.
  4. Score and plot. Score each category, plot it on the grid and size each point by annual spend, so the picture shows where the money sits as well as the risk.
  5. Test the strategic items against the market. For each strategic category, assess whether you or the supplier holds the power. That decides whether to exploit, balance or diversify.
  6. Set a strategy for each category. Use the quadrant as the starting point, then adjust for business plans, contract end dates and known risks.
  7. Turn it into actions and review it. Give each category an owner, a plan and a review date. Repeat the exercise at least once a year, and sooner when a market changes sharply.

Kraljic matrix template: strategy by quadrant

Copy this table into a spreadsheet or category plan and adapt the wording to your organisation.

QuadrantProfit impactSupply riskPurchasing strategySupplier relationshipMain actionsWatch for
Strategic itemsHighHighSecure long term value and supplyPartnership with senior sponsors on both sidesJoint plans, close performance management, contingency and exit planning, periodic market testingDependence that weakens your negotiating position over time
Leverage itemsHighLowUse buying power to reduce costCompetitive and commercialAggregate demand, tender regularly, negotiate price structures, consider reverse auctionsSqueezing so hard that service or quality suffers
Bottleneck itemsLowHighSecure supply at acceptable costStable, often longer termBackup suppliers, buffer stock where relevant, longer contracts, specification changes that widen the marketBottlenecks created by your own specifications
Non critical itemsLowLowReduce the cost of buyingLight touch and transactionalStandardise, consolidate suppliers, purchasing cards and simple ordering channels, automated approvalsSpending more on process than the items are worth

For strategic items, add the second test of relative power. Where you hold the stronger position, press for better terms. Where power is balanced, invest in the relationship. Where the supplier dominates, look for ways to diversify, even if that takes years.

Worked example: a technology and services portfolio

Take a hypothetical organisation reviewing its technology and services spend. The procurement lead and the finance director score eight categories from 1 to 5 on each axis, treating anything above 3 as high. The results are illustrative and not drawn from any real client.

CategoryProfit impactSupply riskQuadrantChosen strategy
Core ERP platform and support55StrategicExecutive sponsored partnership, roadmap reviews, renewal planning started two years ahead
Systems integrator for the transformation programme54StrategicOutcome based milestones, named key people, independent assurance of progress
Cloud infrastructure42Leverage, drifting towards strategicCommitted spend negotiated against usage forecasts, portability designed into the architecture
Laptops and end user devices41LeverageOne standard specification, competitive tender every two to three years
Contract developers and testers42LeverageConsolidated onto a small panel with agreed rate cards
Support for a legacy billing system25BottleneckMulti year support agreement, documentation and knowledge transfer, replacement on the roadmap
Specialist industry data feed24BottleneckLonger contract with price caps, alternative source identified and tested
Minor software subscriptions11Non criticalSingle request route, duplicate tools removed, renewals aligned and automated

Two findings stand out. Cloud infrastructure scores as leverage on paper, but every year spent building on one provider’s own services raises the cost of leaving, so the strategy deliberately keeps the exit open.

The legacy billing support is a bottleneck the organisation created itself by customising the system heavily years ago. No buying tactic fixes that. The answer is replacing the system, which turns a procurement problem into a programme decision best supported by independent software selection.

When to use the Kraljic matrix, and when not to

The matrix earns its place in annual category planning, before a major sourcing exercise, when deciding which suppliers need formal relationship management and when a new procurement leader needs a quick view of where the risk sits. It is also a clear way to explain priorities to a board on a single page.

It is less useful in four situations.

  • When the spend data is poor. Fix the classification first, or the grid will be confidently wrong.
  • For a single purchase decision. The tool compares categories. It does not choose a supplier.
  • In markets that move quickly. A score from last year can be wrong today, so fast moving categories need more frequent review.
  • When you need the supplier’s view. The grid shows how important a supplier is to you, not how important you are to the supplier. A key supplier who sees you as a small account will behave accordingly.

Common mistakes

  • Scoring on spend alone. Spend is one input to profit impact. A low value item that can stop a service is a bottleneck however small the invoice.
  • Plotting suppliers instead of categories. One supplier can provide items in several quadrants. Start with categories, then map suppliers onto them.
  • Treating quadrants as permanent. Markets consolidate, technology changes and your own architecture creates lock in. Review positions at least once a year.
  • Using leverage tactics on strategic suppliers. A hard reverse auction against a partner you cannot replace damages the relationship you depend on.
  • Stopping at the picture. A matrix without owners, plans and dates is a slide, not a strategy.
  • Ignoring internal causes. Bespoke specifications, heavy customisation and poor demand forecasting push items into the bottleneck quadrant. Some of the best fixes sit inside your own organisation.

How the matrix fits wider procurement work

The grid is the segmentation step inside category management, where each position becomes a category plan with targets and owners. It also shows where to invest in supplier relationship management, since strategic and bottleneck suppliers usually need structured governance while routine suppliers do not.

The supply risk scores feed straight into third party risk management and into the risk register for critical services. For non critical items, the gains come from a clean procure to pay process rather than from negotiation, and when a strategic category comes up for renewal, a structured request for proposal keeps the comparison fair.

Our procurement consultancy uses this segmentation to decide where effort should go. We hold no reseller agreements and take no commissions from software vendors, so the strategy for each quadrant is set by your interests alone.

Common questions

What is a Kraljic matrix?

A Kraljic matrix is a procurement tool that sorts purchases into four groups by profit impact and supply risk: strategic, leverage, bottleneck and non critical items. Each group needs a different strategy, from close partnership for strategic items to simple, low cost buying for routine ones. Peter Kraljic introduced it in the Harvard Business Review in 1983.

What are the four quadrants of the Kraljic matrix?

Strategic items have high profit impact and high supply risk, so they need partnership and contingency planning. Leverage items have high impact but low risk, so you use buying power and competition. Bottleneck items have low impact but high risk, so the focus is security of supply. Non critical items are low on both, so the aim is efficient, low effort buying.

What is the difference between strategic and leverage items?

Both have high profit impact, but they differ on supply risk. Leverage items come from competitive markets with plenty of capable suppliers, so you can tender, aggregate volume and switch. Strategic items come from a few suppliers you cannot easily replace, so pressing too hard on price can damage a relationship you depend on. They need partnership, governance and contingency instead.

How do you manage bottleneck items?

Focus on security of supply rather than price. Typical actions include qualifying a backup supplier, holding buffer stock where it applies, agreeing longer contracts with price protection, and changing the specification so more suppliers can meet it. Many bottlenecks are self inflicted, created by bespoke specifications or heavy customisation, so look inside the organisation as well as at the market.

Is the Kraljic matrix still relevant?

Yes, as a way to segment spend and decide where procurement effort should go. Its limits are that the scoring relies on judgement, it shows only the buyer’s view of the relationship and it needs regular review as markets change. Used with good spend data, agreed criteria and a test of supplier power for strategic items, it remains one of the most practical tools available.

Related reading: Category management in procurement, Supplier relationship management, Third party risk management and Independent procurement consultancy.

Want a second view of your spend portfolio?

We can score your categories with your team, test the strategic ones against the market and turn the result into plans with owners and dates.

Book a confidential conversation

Sources: Kraljic, P. (1983) Purchasing Must Become Supply Management. Harvard Business Review.

PEF TRACK RECORD£13bnLargestprogramme led5Continentsdelivered across19 yrsSystems delivery£25mLargestsingle saving
CF

Written by Christopher Fagan

Managing Partner, PEF Consulting Partners

Christopher has led systems and transformation delivery for 19 years, including the National Grid separation, the £9bn Energy Bills Support Scheme and the BP Pulse EV charging rollout.