Insights
How to work out the people and skills your strategy needs, compare that with the workforce you will actually have, and close the gap before it shows up in delivery.
By Christopher Fagan, Managing Partner, PEF Consulting Partners
Delivered for and alongside
















Strategic workforce planning is the process of working out the people and skills an organisation will need over the next three to five years to deliver its strategy, and comparing that with the workforce it is likely to have. It then sets out how to close the gap through hiring, training, redeployment, contractors, automation or changes to the work.
Done well, it gives leaders an early warning. Most organisations discover they lack the right people when a programme slips, a regulator asks awkward questions or a key team loses three people in a quarter. A good plan surfaces those risks years earlier, while there is still time to build skills rather than pay a premium to buy them.
In this article
Workforce planning covers several horizons. At the short end sits capacity planning: rosters, shift patterns and how many people you need next month to clear the work. At the long end sits the strategic version, which asks what kind of workforce the strategy needs in three to five years and what has to start now to get there.
It is not the annual headcount budget either. A budget sets how many people you can afford next year. A strategic plan asks which skills you will need, where they will come from and how long they take to develop, and it should inform the budget rather than follow it.
| Aspect | Operational planning | Strategic planning |
|---|---|---|
| Horizon | Weeks to 18 months | Three to five years |
| Main question | Do we have enough people to do the work? | Will we have the right skills to deliver the strategy? |
| Unit of analysis | Headcount, hours and shifts | Skills, capabilities and critical roles |
| Usual owner | Operations and resourcing teams | The executive team, with HR and finance |
| Main output | Rosters, hiring requests and overtime plans | Scenarios, a gap analysis and a set of actions |
Workforce planning is not new. As manpower planning, it was a standard tool for large employers, the armed forces and the public sector for decades, mostly concerned with matching headcount to demand. What changed was the focus: as work became more specialised and skills took longer to build, the harder question became which skills, not how many people.
Two ideas shaped the modern approach. Peter Cappelli, in Talent on Demand (2008), argued that talent should be managed more like a supply chain: forecast demand, accept that the forecast will be wrong and balance building talent internally against buying it in. John Boudreau and Peter Ramstad, in Beyond HR (2007), argued that some roles are pivotal, meaning a change in their quality or availability makes an outsized difference to the strategy, so planning effort should concentrate there.
A workforce planning model does not need specialist software to start. A well built spreadsheet with clear inputs, stated assumptions and a few scenarios will take most organisations a long way. What matters is that demand is linked to the drivers of work rather than to last year’s headcount.
The core inputs are:
Build at least three scenarios, for example the plan, a faster growth case and a constrained case. The point is not to predict the future but to see which gaps appear in every scenario, because those are the ones to act on now. Short term capacity planning can then sit underneath the strategic model, using the same role families and ratios so the two stay consistent.
The figures in this example are invented for illustration. Imagine a regional utility with 400 field engineers whose strategy commits it to a large programme of network upgrades and new connections over four years. The operations team estimates it will need 520 engineers by year four at current productivity, which looks like a gap of 120.
The supply model tells a different story. About 30 engineers leave each year for other employers and 40 are due to retire within four years, most of them from two depots. With no hiring, the team would shrink to 240 by year four, so the real gap is 280, not 120.
Hiring 280 qualified engineers in four years is unlikely in a tight market. The plan therefore combines several responses:
| Response | Contribution by year four |
|---|---|
| Build: an apprenticeship and conversion scheme producing 40 qualified engineers a year from year two | 120 |
| Buy: experienced hires at 25 a year | 100 |
| Borrow: contractors for peak project work | 30 |
| Redesign: better scheduling and digital job packs, worth about 6 per cent in productivity | 30 |
| Total | 280 |
The lesson is in the timing. The apprentices who qualify in year two have to be recruited in the first months of the plan, long before the shortage shows up in the operation, and a retention offer for engineers near retirement, such as phased retirement, buys time while they train. That is what makes the plan strategic rather than reactive.
Copy this table into a spreadsheet and complete one row per role family, working in full time equivalents. Repeat it for each planning year you care about, usually years one, three and five. The first row carries the worked example above at year four.
| Role family | Current FTE | Leavers and retirements | Net internal moves | Projected supply | Demand | Gap | Main actions and owner |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Field engineers (example) | 400 | 160 | 0 | 240 | 520 | 280 | Build 120, buy 100, borrow 30, redesign 30; operations director |
| Critical role family 1 | |||||||
| Critical role family 2 | |||||||
| Other role families | |||||||
| Total |
Projected supply is current FTE, minus leavers and retirements, plus net internal moves. The gap is demand minus projected supply, so a positive number is a shortfall. For critical roles, add a skills view: list the five or six skills that matter most, rate current proficiency against the level needed and note how long each takes to build.
For a ready made starting point, use our free workforce planning template. Over the longer term, the UK’s declining birth rate points to a smaller pool of young people entering work, which is one more reason not to rely on hiring alone.
Strategic workforce planning earns its keep when the strategy changes the work. Typical triggers include:
It is less useful in a small organisation where the leadership team can see every role, in a business fighting for short term survival, or where the strategy itself is still unsettled. In those cases a simple capacity plan and a list of critical roles will do more good than a full model. Settle the strategy first, then plan the workforce.
A workforce plan rarely stands alone. It draws on the operating model, shapes the organisational design that follows and depends on HR data good enough to trust. Where that data is the weak point, HR transformation often has to come first.
When a plan shows roles shrinking in one area and growing in another, the hard part is moving people fairly and quickly. Our workforce transition work covers redeployment, reskilling and the change management that goes with them.
The borrow lever deserves the same care as build and buy. Christopher Fagan’s remit as Project Director on the National Grid separation took in contractor sourcing for capital delivery and operational capacity. Plans that treat contractors as an afterthought tend to find the market has already been booked by someone else.
Strategic workforce planning is the process of forecasting the people and skills an organisation needs to deliver its strategy over the next three to five years, comparing that with the workforce it is likely to have, and choosing actions to close the gap. Those actions include training, hiring, contractors, redeployment, automation and redesigning work. It focuses on critical roles and skills rather than total headcount.
A typical process has six steps. Translate the strategy into the work it creates or removes. Segment the workforce and identify critical roles. Model future supply from leavers, retirements and internal moves. Model future demand from the drivers of work. Analyse capacity and skills gaps by role and year. Then choose actions such as build, buy, borrow or redesign, assign owners and review the plan regularly.
Capacity planning is short term and operational: making sure there are enough people, hours and shifts to meet demand over the coming weeks or months. Strategic workforce planning looks three to five years ahead and asks whether the organisation will have the right skills to deliver its strategy. The two should share the same role families and productivity ratios so they stay consistent.
A workforce planning model is a spreadsheet or tool that projects workforce supply and demand by role family over time. Supply comes from current headcount adjusted for leavers, retirements and internal moves. Demand comes from work drivers such as customers, assets or projects, divided by productivity ratios. Running several scenarios shows which gaps appear whatever happens, and those are the ones to act on first.
Start with the skills your strategy needs in three to five years, then list the handful that matter most for each critical role. Rate current proficiency across the team against the level required, using evidence such as assessments, certifications and manager reviews. The difference is the skills gap. Note how long each skill takes to build, because that decides whether to train, hire or contract.
Related reading: People and change consultancy, What is an operating model?, The change curve explained and Change readiness assessment.
We help leadership teams turn strategy into a workforce plan they can act on, from the first model through to the redeployment and change that follow.
Book a confidential conversation
Sources: Cappelli, P. (2008) Talent on Demand: Managing Talent in an Age of Uncertainty. Harvard Business Press.; Boudreau, J. W. and Ramstad, P. M. (2007) Beyond HR: The New Science of Human Capital. Harvard Business School Press.
Written by Christopher Fagan
Managing Partner, PEF Consulting Partners
Christopher has led systems and transformation delivery for 19 years, including the National Grid separation, the £9bn Energy Bills Support Scheme and the BP Pulse EV charging rollout.
Where next