Insights

The change curve: stages, signs and what leaders should do

The change curve describes how people’s morale and performance tend to move when something they rely on changes. Here is where it came from, how to read each stage and what leaders should do at each point to make the dip shorter and shallower.

By Christopher Fagan, Managing Partner, PEF Consulting Partners

£13bnlargest programme delivered
19 yrssenior systems delivery
5 continentsdelivered across
£25msaving on a single programme

Delivered for and alongside

ShellBPCapitaBaringaOfgemSmart DCCInsightsFlui TechnologiesExxonMobilVodafoneConstellation SoftwareDeloittePwCEYNational GridElexon

The change curve is a simple model of how people tend to react when something they rely on changes: an early drop in morale and performance, a low point, then a gradual climb as they test the new way and commit to it. Leaders use it to plan support for each stage rather than expecting instant acceptance.

It is one of the most borrowed ideas in change management and one of the most misused. Used well, it stops a programme panicking when performance dips after go live. Used badly, it becomes a way of labelling anyone who raises a fair concern as being in denial.

Where the Kübler Ross change curve comes from

The model starts with Elisabeth Kübler Ross, a Swiss born psychiatrist who worked in the United States, and her 1969 book On Death and Dying. Drawing on conversations with terminally ill patients, she described five stages that people often went through: denial, anger, bargaining, depression and acceptance. The book was about dying, not about reorganisations or new finance systems.

Management trainers and consultants later borrowed the shape for organisational change, on the reasoning that losing a familiar job, team or way of working triggers a smaller version of the same reactions. The stages were redrawn as a curve, with time along the bottom and morale or performance up the side. That picture is what most people now mean by the Kübler Ross change curve.

It is worth being clear about what the model is: a heuristic, a useful way of thinking, not a law of human behaviour. Grief researchers have found little evidence that people move through fixed stages in a set order, and Kübler Ross herself, writing later with David Kessler in On Grief and Grieving (2005), said the stages were never meant to be a tidy sequence that everyone follows.

In practice people skip stages, loop back and sit in two at once. Treat the curve as a prompt for what to look for, not as a prediction of what will happen.

The stages of the change curve

There is no single official version. Most organisational versions compress the original five stages into four or five phases, and the labels vary from one source to the next. The version below is the one we find most practical, because each stage calls for a different response from leaders.

  1. Shock and denial. The news lands. People look for reasons it will not affect them, or assume it will be quietly dropped like the last initiative. Performance often holds up for a while because nothing has actually changed yet.
  2. Frustration and resistance. The change becomes real. People push back, question the business case, defend the old way and try to negotiate exceptions, which is where the original bargaining stage tends to show up.
  3. The low point. Energy and confidence drop. People are using the new way and finding it slower and harder than the old one. This is usually where performance is weakest and where sponsors are most tempted to reverse course.
  4. Exploration. People start testing the new way properly, finding shortcuts and asking better questions. Mistakes still happen, but they are the kind people learn from.
  5. Acceptance and commitment. The new way becomes the normal way. People start improving it rather than comparing it with what came before.

The horizontal axis is time, and the vertical axis is usually labelled morale, competence or performance. The exact shape matters less than two practical points. Performance usually gets worse before it gets better, and different groups will be at different points on the curve at the same moment.

Emotional response to change: signs and what leaders should do

The emotional response to change is much easier to manage when you know what each stage looks like on the ground. The table maps each stage to the signs you are likely to see and the leadership response that tends to help. Copy it into your change plan and add a column for the groups you think are at each stage.

StageSigns you will see and hearWhat leaders should do
Shock and denialQuiet briefings with few questions. Comments such as “this will never actually happen”. Business as usual carries on and few people read the updates.Explain plainly what is changing, why, when, and what is not changing. Repeat it through line managers rather than relying on one announcement. Give dates and specifics rather than slogans.
Frustration and resistancePushback in meetings, challenges to the business case, requests for exceptions, informal groups forming against the change, talk of leaving.Listen properly and log every objection. Fix the ones that expose real design problems and say so publicly. Be firm about what is not negotiable and explain why.
The low pointOutput drops, errors and workarounds rise, help desk queues grow, people disengage or go quiet.Put extra support where the work happens: floor walkers, quick fixes and a clear route to escalate. Protect the team from new demands. Do not reverse the decision because of a dip you could have predicted.
ExplorationQuestions move from why to how. People share tips, ask for more advanced training and suggest improvements.Give people room to experiment. Capture good workarounds and spread them. Recognise early adopters in front of their peers.
Acceptance and commitmentThe new way is used without prompting, old spreadsheets and reports fall away, and people defend the new process to newcomers.Switch off the old way for good. Hand ownership of improvements to the business. Record lessons learned and move support into business as usual.

A worked example: replacing a finance system

Take a hypothetical business with a finance team of 40 people replacing a finance system it has used for 15 years. The leadership team has known about the decision for six months by the time it is announced. Most of the finance team hear about it for the first time at an all staff briefing.

In the first few weeks the accounts payable team sit in shock and denial, and some assume the project will stall like the last one. The management accountants, who built most of the spreadsheets around the old system, move quickly into frustration. They question whether the new system can produce the reports they rely on.

Go live lands at the start of a quarter, and the first month end close on the new system is the low point. Close takes longer, reconciliations throw up errors, and two experienced people start talking about leaving. A director suggests running the old system in parallel for another six months.

A programme that understands the curve has planned for this. It has floor walkers in the finance office for the first two closes as part of a proper hypercare period, a daily fifteen minute call to clear issues, and a short list of fixes that can be made in days rather than weeks. It also holds the line on switching off the old system, because a long parallel run keeps everyone at the bottom of the curve for longer.

By the third close the questions have changed from why to how. By the sixth, the team is asking for reports the old system could never have produced. That is acceptance, and it is the moment to hand ownership of further improvements back to the finance team.

How to use the change curve model on a programme

The model earns its place when it changes what you plan and budget for. Six steps make it practical.

  1. Split people into groups by impact. Use a stakeholder analysis to group people by how much the change touches their daily work. A finance team losing its spreadsheets and a sales team getting a new expenses app are on very different curves.
  2. Place each group honestly. Leaders who have known for months are often near acceptance when they make the announcement, while their teams are only starting at shock. That gap explains a lot of frustration on both sides.
  3. Plan support by stage. Shock needs clear information, resistance needs listening and decisions, the low point needs practical help, and exploration needs room. Build those activities into your change management plan with owners and dates.
  4. Time communications to the stage. Detailed training material sent during shock is mostly ignored, while the same material during exploration gets used. A communication plan that sequences messages by audience makes this much easier.
  5. Measure rather than guess. Short pulse surveys, help desk ticket themes, error rates and attendance at drop in sessions tell you where each group really is. Running a change readiness assessment before go live gives you a baseline to compare against.
  6. Resource the dip. Budget for extra support, temporary cover or reduced targets during the low point. If your plan assumes performance holds steady through go live, the plan is wrong.

When the curve helps and when it does not

The curve is most useful when a change has real personal impact: restructures, new roles, relocations, outsourcing, mergers and new core systems that change how people spend their day. It helps sponsors hold their nerve through the dip, and it gives line managers a shared language for what they are seeing.

It is much less useful for small changes with little personal impact, such as a new form or a reporting tweak, and for changes people actively asked for. It is no help as a timetable either, because nobody can promise that a team will reach acceptance by March.

Where the change curve stops being useful altogether is when it is used to explain away every objection. Resistance is sometimes the most valuable feedback a programme gets. If a team says the new process cannot handle a case they deal with every week, check before you file it under frustration.

Common mistakes

  • Treating it as a straight line. People loop back, especially when a second change lands before the first has settled.
  • Labelling people. Telling someone they are in denial ends the conversation and usually deepens the resistance.
  • Forgetting the leadership lag. Senior people went through their own curve months earlier and then wonder why everyone else is so slow.
  • Announcing and disappearing. Visible sponsors matter most at the low point, which is exactly when many move on to the next priority.
  • Pulling support at go live. The low point usually arrives after go live, not before it, so that is when support should peak.
  • Reading quiet as acceptance. Silence often means shock or disengagement rather than agreement.
  • Reversing the decision in the dip. A predictable fall in performance is not evidence that the change was wrong.

How it fits with Kotter, ADKAR and Lewin

The curve describes how people feel. It does not tell a leadership team what to do next, or explain why one particular person is stuck. That is why it works best alongside other models, each covering a different part of the problem.

For a broader view of how these pieces fit together, start with our guide to what change management is and how it works. It sets out the process end to end and where each model earns its keep.

Where this fits in wider delivery work

The curve is not a separate workstream with its own slide deck. It should shape the plan, the support budget and the criteria for go live. A programme that expects the dip staffs up for it, while one that does not tends to read the dip as failure and make expensive decisions in a hurry.

Christopher Fagan has spent 19 years delivering systems and transformation. Finance system replacements, whether on Oracle, Microsoft Dynamics, NetSuite, Sage or SAP S/4HANA, are where the dip after go live is easiest to see and easiest to plan for. Our change management and adoption work builds this in from the start: we design and build alongside your team, so the people who have to live with the change help shape it rather than receiving a finished plan.

Common questions

What is the change curve?

The change curve is a model of how people typically respond to significant change at work. Morale and performance tend to fall after a change is announced and introduced, reach a low point, then recover as people explore the new way and commit to it. Leaders use it to plan the right support at each stage instead of expecting instant acceptance.

What are the stages of the Kübler Ross change curve?

Kübler Ross’s original five stages were denial, anger, bargaining, depression and acceptance, describing how terminally ill patients responded to their situation. Organisational versions usually adapt these into shock and denial, frustration and resistance, a low point, exploration, and acceptance and commitment. The labels vary between versions, but the shape is the same: a dip, then a recovery.

How long does it take people to move through the change curve?

There is no standard timescale. It depends on how much the change affects someone’s daily work, how well it is explained and supported, and what else is changing at the same time. A minor process change might take weeks, while a restructure or a new core system can take months. Plan support around evidence of where groups actually are, not a fixed timetable.

Is the change curve based on evidence?

Only loosely. It began as a description of how dying patients responded to their situation, and grief researchers have found little evidence that people pass through fixed stages in order. It is best treated as a heuristic: a useful prompt for what to look for and how to support people, rather than a scientific prediction of how anyone will behave.

How do you use the change curve in change management?

Group people by how much the change affects them, estimate where each group is on the curve, and plan support for that stage: information during shock, listening during resistance, practical help at the low point and room to experiment during exploration. Check your estimates with pulse surveys and help desk data, and keep support in place until well after go live.

Related reading: What is change management?, The ADKAR model explained, Kotter’s 8 step change model and Change readiness assessment.

Planning a change your people will feel?

We help leadership teams plan the people side of system and organisational change, then stay with them through go live and the dip that follows. Tell us what is changing and we will give you a straight view of where the risks are.

Book a confidential conversation

Sources: Elisabeth Kübler Ross, On Death and Dying, 1969; Elisabeth Kübler Ross and David Kessler, On Grief and Grieving, 2005

PEF TRACK RECORD£13bnLargestprogramme led5Continentsdelivered across19 yrsSystems delivery£25mLargestsingle saving
CF

Written by Christopher Fagan

Managing Partner, PEF Consulting Partners

Christopher has led systems and transformation delivery for 19 years, including the National Grid separation, the £9bn Energy Bills Support Scheme and the BP Pulse EV charging rollout.