Insights

Kotter’s 8 step change model: the steps, examples and pitfalls

John Kotter’s eight steps remain the most quoted framework for leading organisational change. Here is what each step asks of leaders, what good looks like, where programmes usually slip, and how the later accelerators version differs.

By Christopher Fagan, Managing Partner, PEF Consulting Partners

£13bnlargest programme delivered
19 yrssenior systems delivery
5 continentsdelivered across
£25msaving on a single programme

Delivered for and alongside

ShellBPCapitaBaringaOfgemSmart DCCInsightsFlui TechnologiesExxonMobilVodafoneConstellation SoftwareDeloittePwCEYNational GridElexon

Kotter’s 8 step change model is a sequence for leading organisational change, set out by John Kotter of Harvard Business School: create urgency, build a guiding coalition, form a vision, communicate it, remove barriers, generate short term wins, sustain the momentum and anchor the change in the culture. Each step builds on the one before.

It is written for the people leading a change rather than the people living through it. That is its strength, because a change that is poorly led rarely recovers further down the organisation. It is also its limit, because it says little about how individuals actually adopt a new way of working.

Where Kotter’s 8 step change model comes from

John Kotter, a professor at Harvard Business School, first set out the ideas in a 1995 Harvard Business Review article, Leading Change: Why Transformation Efforts Fail. He drew on more than a hundred companies he had watched try to transform themselves, and organised what he saw into eight errors that undermine change, among them not creating enough urgency and declaring victory too soon.

A year later he turned those errors into a positive sequence in his book Leading Change (1996). That version, with eight steps run broadly in order, is what most people mean when they talk about the Kotter model. His central warning was that skipping steps only creates the appearance of speed, and that a serious mistake at any step can undo the progress made at the others.

In 2014 Kotter published Accelerate, which reworked the steps into eight accelerators for organisations that need to change continuously rather than once. The differences are covered further down.

The 8 steps of change, one by one

1. Create a sense of urgency

Help enough people see, with evidence, why the current position cannot continue and what opportunity is being missed. Urgency is not panic. It is a shared, specific understanding of why this matters now.

2. Build a guiding coalition

Assemble a group with enough authority, expertise, credibility and leadership to drive the change, and get them working as a team. A steering committee that meets monthly to receive slides is not a guiding coalition.

3. Form a strategic vision

Describe what the organisation will look like after the change and how it will get there, in terms people can picture. Kotter’s own test was whether you could explain the vision in about five minutes and get understanding and interest back.

4. Communicate the vision

Use every channel, repeatedly, and make sure leaders’ behaviour matches the message. A launch event and an intranet page are not communication. People believe what leaders do far more than what they say.

5. Remove barriers and empower action

Take away the obstacles that stop people acting on the vision: structures, processes, systems, incentives and sometimes individual managers who block progress. Kotter called this empowering broad based action.

6. Generate short term wins

Plan for visible, unambiguous improvements early, and recognise the people who delivered them. Wins buy credibility with doubters and give sponsors evidence that the change is working.

7. Consolidate gains and keep going

Use the credibility from early wins to tackle bigger problems, change more systems and structures, and bring in new people to lead the next phase. This is where Kotter warned against declaring victory too soon.

8. Anchor the change in the culture

Make the new way the normal way by connecting it to results, building it into how people are hired, promoted and rewarded, and making sure the next generation of leaders carries it on. Until then, old habits are only waiting for attention to move elsewhere.

Kotter 8 step change model template: what good looks like

Use the table as a checklist at each programme board or stage gate. For each step, ask whether you can point to evidence for the middle column, and whether anything in the right hand column sounds familiar.

StepWhat good looks likeCommon failure
1. Create urgencyLeaders can state the problem in one or two sentences, with evidence. Managers below them can say the same thing in their own words.A burning platform presentation that frightens people without telling them what to do next.
2. Guiding coalitionA small group with real authority meets often, decides quickly and is seen to decide. The business owns it, not the programme team.A large steering committee that reviews status and defers decisions to the next meeting.
3. Strategic visionA short description of the future state and how you will get there, with measures people can track.A slogan, or a long strategy document that nobody below the board can explain.
4. Communicate the visionRepeated, two way communication through line managers, with leaders visibly changing their own behaviour.One launch event, a newsletter and then silence for three months.
5. Remove barriersBlockers are named and dealt with, including policies, systems, incentives and senior people.Old targets and approval routes left in place, so people are asked to change while being measured on the old way.
6. Short term winsPlanned, visible improvements in the first months that clearly link to the vision.Wins announced but not felt, or claimed for work that would have happened anyway.
7. Sustain momentumEarly credibility is used to take on bigger changes, and governance stays in place after go live.Declaring victory at go live, standing the team down and watching old habits return.
8. Anchor in the cultureNew ways are built into roles, performance measures, induction and promotion decisions.The new process exists alongside the old reports and spreadsheets, which quietly win.

A worked example: consolidating finance into a shared service

Take a hypothetical group with three regional finance teams that wants to bring transaction processing into one shared service centre. Here is how the eight steps might play out.

  • Urgency. The finance director shows the board, then each regional team, how long month end takes in each region and how much effort is duplicated. The case is specific and the figures are the group’s own.
  • Coalition. The coalition includes the three regional finance leads, not just head office, and one of them, respected across the business, jointly leads it.
  • Vision. One page covers which work moves, which stays local, what the service will look like in a year and what it means for each team.
  • Communication. Regional leads brief their own teams first, then hold monthly question sessions. The finance director visits each site rather than relying on video calls.
  • Barriers. Regional approval limits are aligned and the old local spreadsheets get a retirement date. A manager who keeps telling their team nothing will really change is moved off the programme.
  • Short term wins. Supplier payments move first, because the benefit shows quickly and suppliers notice.
  • Momentum. Credibility from the first move is used to bring over harder processes, such as intercompany accounting and fixed assets.
  • Culture. Service levels become part of the finance leadership team’s objectives, and new joiners are inducted into the shared service rather than the old regional way.

Nothing in that example is unusual. What makes the difference is doing every step deliberately, rather than assuming the business case will carry people along on its own.

How the Kotter change model changed in Accelerate

In Accelerate (2014), Kotter argued that the original sequence suits a single, large change but struggles in organisations that face constant change. He kept the eight elements and reframed them as accelerators: create a sense of urgency, build a guiding coalition, form a strategic vision and initiatives, enlist a volunteer army, enable action by removing barriers, generate short term wins, sustain acceleration and institute change.

Three differences matter in practice. The accelerators run concurrently and continuously rather than in a fixed order, and they are driven by a large group of volunteers from across the organisation rather than a small core team. They also operate through a network that sits alongside the normal hierarchy, which Kotter calls a dual operating system, so the day job carries on while the change network moves faster.

For a single programme with a clear end, such as a system replacement or a restructure, the original eight steps are usually enough. For a business trying to build a habit of change, the accelerators are the better fit.

When to use it and when not to

Kotter’s 8 step change model works best for large, organisation wide change led from the top, where leaders need to line up behind one direction and mobilise a lot of people quickly. Restructures, mergers, new operating models and major system replacements all fit.

It is weaker in three situations. It says little about how individuals move through a change, so pair it with a people level model such as Prosci’s ADKAR model or the change curve. It assumes a leadership team that can agree, which is not always true in partnerships or joint ventures.

Its evidence base is also mostly case experience rather than controlled research, a point academic reviewers have made, so treat it as a disciplined checklist rather than a guarantee. If you need to explain to a board why change needs preparation before launch, the simpler unfreeze, change, refreeze model from Kurt Lewin is often the quicker way in.

Common mistakes with Kotter’s 8 steps

  • Confusing urgency with fear. Frightening people without showing them a way forward produces defensiveness, not action.
  • A coalition in name only. If the group cannot make decisions between meetings, it is a committee. A good programme sponsor makes sure it has the authority it needs.
  • Running the steps as stage gates. The steps overlap, and communication does not stop when barrier removal starts.
  • Under communicating. Leaders who have lived with the change for months forget that their teams heard about it once.
  • Leaving blockers in place. Especially senior ones. Everyone notices, and everyone draws the same conclusion.
  • Manufactured wins. Wins that people cannot feel in their own work damage credibility rather than build it.
  • Stopping at go live. Steps seven and eight happen after the system is switched on, which is exactly when many programme teams are stood down.

How it fits with other models and delivery work

Kotter’s 8 step change model gives you the leadership sequence, but it only works if you know who you are leading. A proper stakeholder analysis tells you who needs to be in the coalition, who is likely to resist and who will carry the message. The steps then belong in your change management plan with owners and dates, not in a separate leadership document. For the wider picture, see our guide to what change management involves.

Christopher Fagan was Global Transformation Director on the BP Pulse EV charging rollout, where PEF held the main contract, and across his career he has led programmes worth up to £13bn on five continents. Programmes of that size make the same point Kotter does: a coalition that meets, decides and is seen to decide matters more than any launch event. Our change management and adoption team works inside your programme, designing and building alongside your people rather than handing over a framework and leaving.

Common questions

What are Kotter’s 8 steps of change?

Kotter’s eight steps are: create a sense of urgency, build a guiding coalition, form a strategic vision, communicate the vision, remove barriers so people can act, generate short term wins, consolidate gains and keep up momentum, and anchor the new approaches in the culture. John Kotter first described them in a 1995 Harvard Business Review article and then in his 1996 book Leading Change.

What is the difference between Kotter’s 8 steps and the 8 accelerators?

The original eight steps, from Leading Change (1996), run broadly in sequence and are led by a small guiding coalition. The eight accelerators, from Accelerate (2014), cover similar ground but run at the same time and continuously, are driven by a large volunteer group from across the organisation, and operate through a network alongside the normal hierarchy.

Is Kotter’s change model still relevant?

Yes, as a leadership checklist. The problems it describes, such as weak urgency, a coalition without authority, too little communication and declaring victory too soon, still sink programmes. Its limits are that it is top down, says little about individual adoption and rests mainly on case experience, so most practitioners pair it with a people level model such as ADKAR.

What is a guiding coalition in Kotter’s model?

A guiding coalition is the group that leads the change. Kotter said it needs enough position power, expertise, credibility and leadership to drive the change, and that its members must work as a team. In practice it should be small, include respected people from the business as well as senior leaders, and be able to make decisions between formal meetings.

How does Kotter’s model compare with ADKAR?

Kotter’s model is written for the leaders running a change and sets out what they must do across the organisation. Prosci’s ADKAR model looks at each individual and what they need, from awareness to reinforcement, before they change. They work well together: Kotter to organise the leadership effort, and ADKAR to find out why particular groups are not moving.

Related reading: The change curve explained, The ADKAR model, Lewin’s change model and What a good programme sponsor does.

Leading a change that has to land?

We work with sponsors and leadership teams to plan and run the leadership side of change, then stay through go live and beyond. Tell us where your programme is and we will give you a straight assessment of what needs to happen next.

Book a confidential conversation

Sources: John P. Kotter, Leading Change: Why Transformation Efforts Fail, Harvard Business Review, 1995; John P. Kotter, Leading Change, Harvard Business School Press, 1996; John P. Kotter, Accelerate, Harvard Business Review Press, 2014

PEF TRACK RECORD£13bnLargestprogramme led5Continentsdelivered across19 yrsSystems delivery£25mLargestsingle saving
CF

Written by Christopher Fagan

Managing Partner, PEF Consulting Partners

Christopher has led systems and transformation delivery for 19 years, including the National Grid separation, the £9bn Energy Bills Support Scheme and the BP Pulse EV charging rollout.