Insights

Stakeholder analysis: template, mapping and the power interest grid

How to work out who can make or break a change, where each person stands and what you need from them, with a copyable template and a hypothetical worked example.

By Christopher Fagan, Managing Partner, PEF Consulting Partners

£13bnlargest programme delivered
19 yrssenior systems delivery
5 continentsdelivered across
£25msaving on a single programme

Delivered for and alongside

ShellBPCapitaBaringaOfgemSmart DCCInsightsFlui TechnologiesExxonMobilVodafoneConstellation SoftwareDeloittePwCEYNational GridElexon

Stakeholder analysis is the process of identifying everyone who can affect or will be affected by a change, assessing their interest, influence and current stance, and deciding how to engage each of them. Done properly, it tells a programme whose support it needs, where resistance will come from and who on the team owns each relationship.

Programmes rarely fail because nobody drew a plan. They stall because a decision maker was never really on board, a group that had to change its way of working was told too late, or someone with a quiet veto was missed entirely. Stakeholder work is how you find those people early, while there is still time to bring them with you.

What is stakeholder analysis?

A stakeholder is any person, group or organisation with an interest in the outcome or the power to shape it. That includes the obvious ones, such as the sponsor, the board and the teams whose work will change. It also includes the less obvious ones: regulators, unions, key suppliers, customers, auditors and the people who run the systems you plan to switch off.

The analysis has three jobs. It identifies who matters, it assesses each stakeholder on a few consistent dimensions, usually interest, influence and stance, and it turns that assessment into a decision about how, how often and by whom each one is engaged. The third job is the one most often skipped, and the one that makes the difference.

Where it comes from

The stakeholder idea entered mainstream management through R. Edward Freeman’s 1984 book Strategic Management: A Stakeholder Approach. Freeman argued that organisations should be managed with regard to everyone who affects or is affected by them, not only their shareholders.

The power interest grid is usually credited to Mendelow, whose 1981 conference paper on environmental scanning applied the stakeholder concept to how organisations watch the world around them. Strategy textbooks later turned it into the grid most people use today. A useful alternative is the salience model of Mitchell, Agle and Wood, published in 1997, which ranks stakeholders by power, legitimacy and urgency.

Stakeholder mapping and the power interest grid

Stakeholder mapping places each stakeholder on a simple chart so the team can see the whole picture at once. The most common version is the power interest grid, with power or influence on one axis and interest on the other. Each quarter suggests a default approach:

  • High power, high interest: manage closely. Involve them in decisions, meet regularly and never let them be surprised.
  • High power, low interest: keep satisfied. Give them what they need to stay comfortable without overloading them, and watch for anything that could suddenly raise their interest.
  • Low power, high interest: keep informed. Update them and listen to them. They often know where the practical problems are, and together they can gain influence quickly.
  • Low power, low interest: monitor. Light touch communication, reviewed as the change develops.

Two cautions apply. Power is not the same as seniority: the payroll manager who has to sign off parallel running, or the union representative whose members run the depots, can hold more practical influence than a director. Positions on the grid also move, so a map drawn at initiation and never revisited will mislead you by go live. Our stakeholder map template gives you a ready made grid to plot against.

How to do a stakeholder analysis, step by step

  1. Be clear about the change. Write down what is changing, when, and what you need from people: decisions, money, staff time, changed behaviour or simply no objection.
  2. List stakeholders widely. Ask who could stop this, who has to do something differently, who will notice if it goes wrong and who is affected but has no voice in the room. Split broad groups such as “the business” or “staff” into the parts that will react differently.
  3. Assess interest and influence. Use evidence where you have it: formal authority, budget control, control of resources, expertise, networks and a track record of shaping decisions.
  4. Record current and desired stance. A simple five point scale works: opposed, sceptical, neutral, supportive, champion. The distance between where someone is and where you need them to be is what the engagement has to close.
  5. Plot and prioritise. Put everyone on the grid and pick out the few relationships that will decide the outcome.
  6. Choose the approach and the owner. For each stakeholder, decide how they will be engaged, how often, and which person on the team has the relationship to do it.
  7. Review on a rhythm. Revisit the analysis at each phase gate and whenever something significant changes, such as a new director or a delayed go live.

Stakeholder analysis template

The template below is a stakeholder analysis matrix: one row per stakeholder, with the same columns for everyone so they can be compared. The first row explains what goes in each column. Copy it into a spreadsheet, and treat the finished version as confidential, because candid notes on people’s positions are not for general circulation.

StakeholderRoleInterestInfluenceCurrent stanceDesired stanceEngagement approachOwner
Name or groupTheir role in the organisation and in the changeWhat they care about and stand to gain or lose; high, medium or lowHow far they can shape the outcome, and through what; high, medium or lowOpposed, sceptical, neutral, supportive or champion, with the evidenceWhere you need them to be, and by whenHow, how often and through which channel they will be engagedThe team member who owns the relationship

Worked example: a new scheduling system at a hypothetical utility

This example is hypothetical. A regional utility is replacing the system that schedules its field engineers, and the operations director sponsoring the change plans to brief the workforce once the contract is signed. A short analysis changes that plan.

StakeholderRoleInterestInfluenceCurrent stanceDesired stanceEngagement approachOwner
Operations directorSponsorHigh: owns the productivity targetHighChampionChampionFortnightly one to one; chairs the steering groupProgramme director
Field engineersDaily users of the new appHigh: changes how their day is plannedMedium as a groupScepticalSupportive by the end of the pilotPilot depot, user group, early demonstrationsChange lead
Union representativesRepresent field staffHigh: working patterns and use of location dataHighNeutralSupportiveEarly consultation on working practices and data useHR director
Scheduling team leadRuns the current scheduling deskHigh: own role will changeHigh informally: trusted by engineersOpposedSupportiveJoin the design team and shape the new desk roleOperations director
Finance directorControls the budgetMedium: cost and benefitsHighNeutralSupportiveMonthly benefits tracking; sign off at each gateProgramme director
Incumbent supplierRuns the old system until exitHigh: losing the contractMedium: holds the data and exit supportNeutralCooperative through exitFormal exit plan and regular service meetingsCommercial manager

The matrix shows two things the sponsor had not planned for. The union representatives need consulting before the design is fixed, not after the contract is signed, because the new app changes how engineers’ time and location are recorded. And the scheduling team lead, whose own role is changing, has more influence with the engineers than anyone in management.

Bringing the team lead into the design turns the most likely source of resistance into the most credible voice for the change. Neither point would have surfaced from an organisation chart.

From analysis to a stakeholder engagement plan

The matrix tells you what needs to happen; the stakeholder engagement plan says how. For each priority stakeholder it sets out the objective, the key messages, the channel, the frequency, the owner and how you will know it is working, such as attendance, the questions being raised or sentiment in the pilot. Our communication plan template gives you the structure.

Two other tools help. A RACI matrix settles who decides, who is consulted and who is informed, which removes a surprising amount of friction with senior stakeholders. For the people whose daily work is changing, the ADKAR model helps you plan what each group needs to move from awareness to lasting change, and the change curve is a reminder that dips in support are a normal part of change rather than a sign of failure.

When to use it, and when not to

Use it at the start of any change that affects how people work, before a business case goes to the board, before a major procurement and at mobilisation. Repeat it at each phase gate and whenever a programme stalls, because a stalled programme is very often a stakeholder problem dressed up as a technical one.

Keep it proportionate. A small team change needs a short conversation and a list, not a formal matrix. And do not treat it as a document to be produced: if the analysis is written once, filed and never used to decide who talks to whom, it has cost time and changed nothing.

Common mistakes

  • Mapping job titles, not people. Two directors with the same title can hold very different views and very different influence.
  • Treating groups as one voice. “Staff” or “the business” hides the teams that will react most strongly.
  • Guessing stances. Assumptions made in a project office are often wrong. Talk to people, and record what you heard.
  • Forgetting external stakeholders. Regulators, unions, suppliers and customers can delay a programme as effectively as any board.
  • No owner for each relationship. Engagement that belongs to everyone is done by nobody.
  • Leaving out the sponsor. The sponsor is a stakeholder too, and their stance and available time need managing like anyone else’s.
  • Circulating it carelessly. A frank assessment of a senior colleague’s position can do real damage if it is forwarded. Keep it with the core team.

How it fits wider delivery work

Stakeholder work sits at the centre of change management. It shapes the sponsor’s role, and our guide to what a good programme sponsor does covers that relationship in detail. A change readiness assessment then tells you whether the people affected are ready, and our change management and adoption service puts the engagement plan into practice alongside your team rather than leaving it on paper.

It matters most where stakeholders are many and their interests pull in different directions. Few programmes test this harder than a national support scheme. Our Managing Partner, Christopher Fagan, was Project Director for the £9bn Energy Bills Support Scheme, delivered for Ofgem, BEIS and HMRC, carrying responsibility for the whole implementation and for protecting taxpayers’ money on its way to households, a programme with more stakeholders than most. In our experience, plans survive when the people who could stop them have helped to shape them.

Common questions

What is stakeholder analysis?

Stakeholder analysis is the process of identifying the people and groups who can affect or are affected by a change, assessing each one’s interest, influence and current stance, and deciding how to engage them. Its output is usually a matrix of stakeholders and an engagement plan, with a named owner for each relationship, reviewed regularly as the change progresses.

What is a power interest grid?

A power interest grid is a two by two chart that plots stakeholders by how much power they have over a change and how interested they are in it. High power, high interest stakeholders are managed closely; high power, low interest are kept satisfied; low power, high interest are kept informed; low power, low interest are monitored. Positions move, so review the grid regularly.

How do you do a stakeholder analysis?

Start by defining the change and what you need from people. List stakeholders widely, splitting broad groups into the parts that will react differently. Assess each on interest, influence and current stance, then decide the stance you need. Plot them on a grid, choose an engagement approach and an owner for each priority stakeholder, and review the analysis at every phase gate.

What should a stakeholder analysis template include?

A useful template records, for each stakeholder, who they are, their role, their interest in the change, their influence over it, their current stance, the stance you need, the engagement approach and the team member who owns the relationship. Keeping the same columns for everyone makes stakeholders comparable, and the finished document should be treated as confidential.

What is the difference between stakeholder analysis and a stakeholder engagement plan?

Stakeholder analysis works out who matters, what they care about, how much influence they hold and where they stand. A stakeholder engagement plan turns that into action: objectives, messages, channels, frequency and owners for each priority stakeholder, plus how you will know the engagement is working. The analysis comes first and should be refreshed as the plan runs.

Related reading: Stakeholder map template, The ADKAR model explained, The change curve explained, Communication plan template and What a good programme sponsor does.

Bringing people with you on a major change?

We help sponsors and programme teams work out who matters, plan the engagement and carry it through alongside your people. Talk to us about your programme.

Book a confidential conversation

Sources: R. Edward Freeman, Strategic Management: A Stakeholder Approach, 1984; A. L. Mendelow, Environmental Scanning: The Impact of the Stakeholder Concept, ICIS Proceedings, 1981; Ronald K. Mitchell, Bradley R. Agle and Donna J. Wood, Toward a Theory of Stakeholder Identification and Salience, Academy of Management Review, 1997

PEF TRACK RECORD£13bnLargestprogramme led5Continentsdelivered across19 yrsSystems delivery£25mLargestsingle saving
CF

Written by Christopher Fagan

Managing Partner, PEF Consulting Partners

Christopher has led systems and transformation delivery for 19 years, including the National Grid separation, the £9bn Energy Bills Support Scheme and the BP Pulse EV charging rollout.