Explainer
A transport management system plans loads, picks carriers, tracks vehicles and proves delivery. Here is what the UK market offers shippers and hauliers, from Oracle and SAP to Mandata and Maxoptra, how the vendors charge and how I would choose between them.
By Christopher Fagan, Managing Partner, PEF Consulting Partners
Delivered for and alongside
















A transport management system takes orders that need moving and turns them into loads, routes, carrier bookings and delivery proof, then reconciles what was invoiced against what was agreed. In the UK the term covers two quite different buyers: shippers who own or buy transport to move their own goods, and hauliers and carriers for whom transport is the business. The software overlaps; the priorities do not.
For a shipper the core is planning: consolidating orders into loads, choosing mode and carrier, sequencing multi drop routes and booking delivery slots. Oracle’s data sheet for its Transportation Management product describes operational planning that balances cost, service level and asset use, with multi stop consolidation, pooling, cross docking and three dimensional load building. Blue Yonder sells load building as a named module and Manhattan positions its product as planning through settlement.
For a haulier the core is the job: quoting, order entry, traffic planning, subcontracting, driver communication, proof of delivery, invoicing and compliance. Mandata, which has sold to UK road transport since 1974, describes its product as controlling orders, costing, loads and planning from one platform, with electronic proof of delivery, tracking, defect reporting and a customer portal as add ons. Microlise approaches the same operator from the telematics side, adding journey management, proof of delivery and a transport management system to the data coming off its vehicle units.
Both buyers want the same outcome: fewer empty miles, fewer failed deliveries, and an invoice that matches the work. The route to it differs, which is why the vendor list later in this piece is split the same way.
Carrier management is where a shipper’s TMS earns its keep. The system holds every carrier contract as rates and rules, so that when an order is released it can rate shop: compare the cost and transit time of each eligible carrier and service, apply routing guides and volume commitments, and tender the load. Oracle describes sequential and broadcast tendering over email, web, mobile and XML, with a central rating engine covering truckload, less than truckload, parcel, air, rail and ocean. SAP’s Transportation Management offers interactive freight tendering and a collaboration portal for carriers. Manhattan and Blue Yonder both sell procurement modules that run carrier bids and turn awards into executable rates.
Rate shopping at parcel level is a different discipline. For ecommerce despatch the choice is usually made inside the warehouse system or a multi carrier shipping platform at the pack bench, because the carrier label has to print there. That boundary between WMS and TMS trips up more programmes than any technical fault, which is one reason our WMS selection work always asks who prints the label.
Freight audit closes the loop. Carrier invoices are matched against the tendered rate, the surcharges and the proof of delivery, and exceptions are disputed or approved. Oracle packages this as freight payment, billing and claims; Manhattan describes automated checks that carrier invoices match agreed rates and services; Infios, the former Körber business, lists freight audit and payment within its transport product. In my experience audit recovers enough on its own to justify a TMS for any shipper with a serious third party transport bill, provided somebody owns the exceptions queue rather than letting it fill up.
Once a load is on the road the TMS becomes a visibility tool. Positions arrive from telematics units, driver apps or carrier feeds, estimated arrival times are recalculated against the plan, and exceptions raise alerts before the customer phones. Aptean’s Paragon product pairs its route planning with a live routing toolkit that compares telematics data with the plan and feeds customer facing arrival boards. Microlise builds the same comparison from its own hardware, which is why it appeals to fleets that want one supplier for the unit in the cab and the planning screen.
Proof of delivery has moved from a signed sheet to the driver’s device: signature, photo, barcode scan, time stamp and location, synchronised to the office within seconds. Mandata’s driver app, the Track and Trace package from Access MaxOptra and Routific’s plans all include it, and the enterprise suites offer driver apps for tender acceptance and delivery capture. The practical benefit is not the technology but the dispute it ends: a photo of a pallet on a named dock at a named minute settles most short delivery claims without a phone call.
Customer notifications sit on top: a text with a time window, a tracking link and a live estimate. For home delivery these are now expected rather than appreciated, and the cheaper routing tools include them as standard, usually with SMS messages charged separately.
The driver is the user who decides whether any of this works. If the app adds minutes to each drop, it will be bypassed and the data will be fiction. Involve drivers in the selection and pilot the app on a real route before you sign anything.
I split the market into three groups, and I checked each vendor’s own site in November 2026.
Global suites for shippers with complex, multi modal networks: Oracle Transportation Management, which pairs with Oracle Global Trade Management for customs paperwork; SAP Transportation Management, available on premises or in the cloud and packaged with S/4HANA through SAP’s digital supply chain edition; Manhattan Active Transportation Management, built on the same microservices as its warehouse product and sold in Essentials, Enterprise and Enterprise Premier editions; Blue Yonder Transportation Management, whose named customers include DHL and Carlsberg Group; and Descartes, which runs a multimodal TMS, a freight forwarder TMS and its Global Logistics Network for carrier connectivity. These suit large retailers, manufacturers and logistics providers, and they need an integrator.
UK road transport specialists: Paragon, now sold by Aptean as Paragon Route 360 on its cloud platform, with customers including AO, Wren Kitchens, Greggs and Whistl and an average implementation of 10 to 12 weeks; Mandata of Newcastle upon Tyne, with Go and Enterprise editions of its TMS, more than 7,000 users and private equity backing from Tenzing; and Microlise Group of Nottingham, whose telematics, tachograph management, camera systems and journey management sit alongside its TMS. These are the names you will meet in UK haulage and own fleet distribution.
Route optimisation for smaller fleets: Maxoptra, now sold by The Access Group as Access MaxOptra, with Optimiser, Track and Trace and Complete packages for fleets of five vehicles or more; and Routific, a North American product priced per order rather than per vehicle, which suits local delivery businesses with a handful of vans.
The gap between groups is wide. A haulier with forty trucks does not need Oracle, and a national grocer cannot run on a per order routing app. Match the group to the operation first, then compare within it.
Published prices exist only at the small fleet end, and the pricing basis changes as you move up.
What drives an enterprise quote is predictable: number of depots and users, shipment volume, modes, the modules you take such as procurement, fleet or freight audit, carrier connectivity, and the integrator’s effort. Ask for the price basis in writing and model it at the volumes you expect in three years, not the volumes you have today, because the basis that looks cheapest at launch is rarely cheapest at scale.
Then add the costs the vendor does not quote: telematics hardware and fitting, driver devices and mobile data, carrier onboarding, and the integration into your ERP and warehouse systems, which is usually the largest line after the licences themselves.
A TMS never stands alone. Orders come from the ERP or order management system, loads are built from what the warehouse will have packed, despatch confirmations and proof of delivery flow back, and freight costs land in the ledger against the right customer or cost centre. The boundary with the warehouse system is the one to settle first: who prints the carrier label, who closes the manifest, and whether parcel rate shopping happens at the pack bench or in the TMS. My warehouse management system explainer covers the other side of that line, and our integration practice exists because these decisions get made too late.
Connectivity to carriers is its own workstream. The suites bring networks (Descartes’ Global Logistics Network and the Blue Yonder Network, for example) that save you building each link; smaller tools rely on APIs and emailed tenders. If you already run an integration platform, check what connectors exist before buying another one; my integration platform comparison lists the main options.
How I would decide, in order:
PEF has consultants who have led and dissected transport and warehouse system decisions ahead of, during and after a migration, and the lesson they bring back is consistent: fix the boundaries early, because an integrator will not fix them for you. The supply chain software buyer’s guide puts the TMS in the wider stack, and my distribution ERP piece covers the order side.
Related reading: Warehouse management systems explained, Supply chain software by layer, WMS selection and assurance, Distribution ERP guide, Integration platforms compared, ERP integration.
Route planning software sequences stops and allocates them to vehicles for a day; Access MaxOptra and Routific are examples. A transport management system does that and the rest of the job: order entry, carrier selection and tendering, subcontracting, proof of delivery, freight audit and invoicing, often across several modes. Small fleets usually need routing; shippers with third party carriers and hauliers running an operation need the full system.
Only the small fleet tools publish prices. In November 2026 Routific offered a free plan up to 100 orders a month and 150 US dollars a month up to 1,000 orders, while Access MaxOptra quoted from £200 a month for fleets under five vehicles on a 12 month contract. Mandata, Paragon, Microlise and the global suites from Oracle, SAP, Manhattan, Blue Yonder and Descartes quote individually, driven by depots, users, shipment volume and modules.
If a logistics provider plans and runs your transport, their system does the planning. You still benefit from your own freight audit and visibility, because you are paying the invoices and answering the customers. Many shippers with outsourced transport run a lighter TMS or a visibility platform for tendering, tracking and invoice matching, and leave vehicle level planning to the provider.
Electronic proof of delivery replaces the signed paper note with a capture on the driver’s device: signature, photo, barcode scan, time stamp and location, sent to the office immediately. It matters because it ends disputes about short or late deliveries, speeds up invoicing, and gives customer service a live answer. Mandata, Microlise, Access MaxOptra and Routific all include it in their products.
The names that recur in UK road haulage are Mandata, a Newcastle upon Tyne company selling to the sector since 1974 with Go and Enterprise editions of its TMS, Microlise of Nottingham, which combines telematics with journey management and a TMS, and Paragon, now sold by Aptean for route planning and scheduling. Larger logistics providers also run the global suites from Manhattan, Blue Yonder, Oracle, SAP and Descartes.
Choosing a transport system for the fleet or the freight? We advise independently on transport, warehouse and ERP systems and take nothing from vendors. Tell us how your goods move.
Book a confidential conversation
Independent, client side help on the systems around ERP and CRM: LIMS selection, MES selection, eQMS selection, Computer system validation, HRIS selection and implementation, Payroll implementation, Workday HCM, SAP SuccessFactors, Oracle HCM, Procurement software selection, EAM software selection, WMS selection, Power BI consultancy, and ERP implementation itself. For our fees see pricing.
Written by Christopher Fagan
Managing Partner, PEF Consulting Partners
Christopher has led systems and transformation delivery for 19 years, including the National Grid separation, the £9bn Energy Bills Support Scheme and the BP Pulse EV charging rollout.
Where next