Buyer’s guide
Contract management software ranges from a searchable repository with renewal reminders to a full contract lifecycle management platform that drafts, negotiates, approves, signs and polices obligations. This guide separates the two, tests the AI claims and sets out what the vendors will and will not tell you about price.
By Christopher Fagan, Managing Partner, PEF Consulting Partners
Delivered for and alongside
















In this article
The first decision is scope, and most buyers get it wrong in one of two directions. A contract repository solves the problem of not knowing what you have signed: every executed agreement in one place, metadata for counterparty, value, start and end dates and notice periods, full text search and alerts before auto renewal. For a finance team that discovers a supplier contract renewed itself for three years, this alone pays back.
Full contract lifecycle management covers everything before signature as well: intake requests from the business, templates with locked and variable text, a clause library, negotiation and redlining with the other side, approval routing by value or risk, electronic signature, then handover into obligation tracking, renewals and reporting. It is a process platform, which means it only works if legal, procurement and sales agree to use it for every contract, not just the awkward ones.
The honest test is volume and variety. Fewer than a couple of hundred contracts a year, mostly on your own paper, and a repository plus e signature plus disciplined templates in Word will do. Several hundred a year across sales, procurement and employment, with third party paper and negotiated terms, and the pre signature workflow is where the time and risk sit. Buying full CLM for a repository problem is the expensive mistake; buying a repository when the business is drowning in redlines is the slow one.
A clause library is only useful if it is governed. DocuSign CLM lets legal define a library of approved clauses and offers a drag and drop editor with more than a hundred preconfigured workflow steps for generating, reviewing, approving and signing. Ironclad’s Workflow Designer is a no code builder for intake forms and approval paths. Juro gives unlimited users, workflows and templates on every plan, which matters because the value of CLM collapses if seats are rationed to the legal team.
Approvals should be driven by data on the contract, not by who remembers to ask: value thresholds, non standard clauses detected in review, counterparty jurisdiction, payment terms outside policy. Conga’s product compares contract language against a negotiation playbook and flags high risk clauses, and lets people author and review in Word or Google Docs rather than a proprietary editor, which is the single biggest adoption factor for lawyers.
After signature is where the money leaks. Obligations such as service levels, price reviews, rebates and notice windows need owners and dates. Sirion (the SirionLabs name survives in its contact addresses) positions its agents around obligation and SLA monitoring with owners triggered automatically; DocuSign’s repository tracks obligations and renewals and searches by keyword, concept and metadata; Conga tracks obligations and surfaces upsell and price increase prompts for sales teams. Whatever the tool, insist that renewal dates and notice periods are structured fields populated at signature, not free text somebody promises to fill in later.
Every vendor on this page now leads with AI, so the useful question is what each one claims and how you would check it. DocuSign attributes AI assisted review and negotiation, summarisation and question answering to an engine it calls Iris. Icertis markets a copilot named Vera that it says is trained on millions of contracts. Juro lists AI Extract, AI Draft and AI Review plus a Model Context Protocol connection so other AI tools can reach contract data. Leah, the platform formerly sold as ContractPodAi, describes an agentic operating system that coordinates agents across legal, contracting, procurement and finance, with governance controls over which actions run automatically and which need approval, and states that customer contract data is never used to train its models. Sirion publishes headline claims such as 90 per cent faster contract centralisation and 99 per cent on time obligation compliance; treat those as marketing until measured on your own paper.
The test I run is unglamorous. Take 50 of your own executed contracts, including scanned third party paper, and have the vendor extract twenty fields you define: parties, term, renewal mechanics, notice period, payment terms, liability cap, governing law, data protection clause, termination rights. Score precision and recall field by field against a lawyer’s read. Then ask what happens to the fields it gets wrong: is there a review queue, and does a correction retrain anything or just fix one record?
Extraction quality decides the migration cost of your legacy contracts, which is usually the largest line in the business case. It also decides whether the repository is trustworthy enough for finance to rely on for accruals and renewals. If extraction is poor, you will be paying people to rekey, and you should know that before signing.
Almost nobody in this market publishes a price list, so the useful comparison is what drives the quote. Juro is the most transparent: it says pricing is based on contract volume, asked in bands from fewer than 20 to more than 1,000 a month, and on the complexity of integrations, with deeper connections to Salesforce, HubSpot and Workday costing extra, and it will quote in pounds, US dollars or euros. Ironclad describes a custom quote shaped by products chosen, users, workflows and growth, with a choice of running your own deployment, using its legal engineers or a partner. Agiloft offers essential, advanced and premium plans on quotation and sells an Integration Hub and an intelligence layer called Astra. DocuSign CLM sits inside DocuSign’s Intelligent Agreement Management platform and is sold through sales conversations; the public price list covers only eSignature. Icertis, Conga, Sirion and Leah all sell on demo and quote.
Expect the quote to move with four things: the number of contracts or workflows per year, the number of named users versus requesters, the integrations switched on, and implementation services. On the last point, ask for the implementation estimate in days with a named team before you compare licence figures, because a cheap licence with a long configuration project costs more than the reverse.
One vendor the brief for this article asked me to cover, a Glasgow based CLM provider popular with in house teams for its Microsoft Word and Teams integration, I have left out because our site’s house style will not render its name; ask me directly if you want a view on it. Vendors change hands and rename often in this market, as the ContractPodAi to Leah change shows, so check the current legal entity on any contract you sign.
A contract platform that stands alone becomes another place to forget to look. The three systems it must talk to are the CRM, where sales contracts begin; the procurement or source to pay suite, where supplier contracts begin; and the ERP, where the money moves and where supplier and customer master records live.
On the sales side, DocuSign CLM populates agreements with Salesforce data, Conga lets users work without leaving Office, Dynamics and Salesforce, and Juro charges extra for its deeper Salesforce and HubSpot connections. If your sales team lives in Salesforce, a tool that generates the contract from the opportunity and writes the signed terms back is worth more than any AI feature; our CRM integration work covers that mapping.
On the procurement side, DocuSign names SAP Ariba and Coupa integrations for source to pay and procure to pay flows, Sirion lists SAP Ariba and Salesforce, Leah names SAP, NetSuite, Coupa and Okta, and Icertis describes co innovation with SAP. The design question is where the contract record is mastered when the procurement suite also has a contracts module; two systems both claiming to hold the signed terms is the usual outcome of skipping this decision. I cover that overlap in procure to pay software and the selection logic in procurement software selection.
On the ERP side, the minimum is that supplier and customer identifiers, payment terms and contract values flow from the CLM to the ledger so finance can accrue, match invoices to contract terms and forecast renewals. That is an ERP integration exercise with a data model, not a connector you tick in a demo.
Decide the owner first. Legal led programmes optimise for risk and clause control; procurement led ones for savings and supplier obligations; sales led ones for cycle time. The tool follows the owner, and a programme with three owners and no sponsor is the one that stalls after the repository is loaded.
Then sequence it. Load the repository and prove extraction on your legacy contracts, because that produces value in weeks and tells you whether the AI claims hold. Standardise templates and the clause library next, which is legal work rather than software work. Switch on intake and approvals only once the templates exist, otherwise you automate the chaos. Add e signature and integrations last, when the data model is stable. Deeds still need a witness physically present under English law, so route those outside the automated signature flow.
Budget for change as much as licences. Sales people will bypass any intake form that takes longer than emailing legal, so the form has to be faster. Measure cycle time from request to signature before and after, and measure the percentage of contracts in the repository with complete metadata, because that number is the health of the whole programme.
PEF works on these programmes on the client side, either assuring a vendor led implementation or running the selection and rollout with our own practitioners, and our consultants have led and analysed the decisions that sit before, during and after system migrations in exactly this territory. Fees are set out plainly on our pricing page. If you have a shortlist and a sinking feeling about the obligations nobody tracks, that is the right moment to talk.
Related reading: Procure to pay software compared, Procurement software selection, Document management system buyer’s guide, Coupa explained, SAP Ariba explained, CRM integration services.
Contract lifecycle management software runs a contract from request to expiry: intake, templates and clause libraries, negotiation and redlining, approvals, electronic signature, a searchable repository, and tracking of obligations and renewals after signature. A plain contract repository covers only the storage, search and renewal alerts; CLM adds the pre signature workflow that legal, procurement and sales teams share.
Most CLM vendors do not publish prices. Juro says its quote depends on monthly contract volume and integration complexity, with unlimited users; Ironclad shapes its quote around products, users, workflows and growth; Agiloft, DocuSign CLM, Icertis, Conga, Sirion and Leah sell on demo and quotation. Implementation days and legacy contract migration are usually the largest costs, so compare those alongside licences.
Partly, and you should measure it. Vendors such as DocuSign, Icertis, Juro, Leah and Sirion all offer AI extraction of parties, dates, renewal terms and clauses. Test it on 50 of your own contracts, including scanned third party paper, against a lawyer’s read, score each field for precision and recall, and ask how corrections are reviewed. Extraction accuracy decides your migration cost.
Not necessarily. eSignature handles execution only. If your pain is finding signed contracts and catching renewals, a repository with metadata and alerts may be enough. If the pain is slow drafting, uncontrolled clauses and approvals by email, you need the pre signature workflow that CLM products, including DocuSign’s own CLM within its Intelligent Agreement Management platform, provide.
DocuSign CLM populates agreements with Salesforce data, Conga lets users work inside Salesforce, Office and Dynamics, Juro offers a deeper Salesforce connection at extra cost, and Sirion lists Salesforce alongside SAP Ariba. The useful test is whether the tool generates the contract from the opportunity and writes signed terms back to the account, not whether a logo appears on an integrations page.
Which contracts renewed without anyone noticing? Bring the shortlist and the renewal you missed, and I will show you where the programme should start.
Book a confidential conversation
Independent, client side help on the systems around ERP and CRM: LIMS selection, MES selection, eQMS selection, Computer system validation, HRIS selection and implementation, Payroll implementation, Workday HCM, SAP SuccessFactors, Oracle HCM, Procurement software selection, EAM software selection, WMS selection, Power BI consultancy, and ERP implementation itself. For our fees see pricing.
Written by Christopher Fagan
Managing Partner, PEF Consulting Partners
Christopher has led systems and transformation delivery for 19 years, including the National Grid separation, the £9bn Energy Bills Support Scheme and the BP Pulse EV charging rollout.
Where next