Comparison

FP&A software compared: Workday Adaptive Planning, Planful, Vena, Board, Anaplan and Jedox

Spreadsheets break at about the third entity and the fifth reforecast. I have compared six planning tools UK finance teams shortlist, Workday Adaptive Planning, Planful, Vena, Board, Anaplan and Jedox, on what they do, how they reach the general ledger, how they are priced and who each suits.

By Christopher Fagan, Managing Partner, PEF Consulting Partners

19 yrssenior systems delivery
7finance platforms delivered
39 daysearly on an Oracle to Dynamics migration
0licences or commissions

Delivered for and alongside

ShellBPCapitaBaringaOfgemSmart DCCInsightsFlui TechnologiesExxonMobilVodafoneConstellation SoftwareDeloittePwCEYNational GridElexon

What FP&A software does that a spreadsheet cannot

A financial planning and analysis tool holds one governed model of the business: the chart of accounts and its dimensions, the drivers that turn headcount, volumes and prices into a profit and loss, balance sheet and cash flow, and the versions of the plan over time. Actuals load from the ledger on a schedule, budget holders enter numbers through a workflow with approvals, and variance reporting comes out the other end without rekeying. Most of the tools add consolidation, so intercompany eliminations and currency translation sit beside the forecast.

The products differ on three axes that matter more than the feature lists. First, the interface: Vena and Jedox keep Excel as the front end, Workday Adaptive Planning and Planful offer Excel add ins over a web model, and Board and Anaplan expect you to live in their own environment. Second, the modelling engine: a fixed financial structure that is quick to stand up, or a general purpose multidimensional engine that plans supply chain and sales territories as happily as opex.

Before you shortlist, settle whether you are buying budgeting and forecasting, consolidation and close, or operational planning across the business. The answer changes the vendor order, and it is the first question I ask when the ERP’s own budgeting module has run out.

Workday Adaptive Planning and Planful

Workday Adaptive Planning is the most widely deployed of the six, with Workday claiming more than 7,000 customers. It covers budgets, rolling forecasts, P&L, balance sheet and cash flow, workforce and sales planning, and a separate Close and Consolidation package. The engine is Workday’s Elastic Hypercube, reporting runs through OfficeConnect for Excel, Word and PowerPoint, and the AI features are a Predictive Forecaster and a Planning Agent that answers questions and investigates variances. It is sold alongside Workday Financial Management and HCM but connects to any ERP or ledger, and most UK customers I come across run it against NetSuite, Sage Intacct or Dynamics.

Planful is the former Host Analytics, headquartered in San Francisco, privately held and backed by Vector Capital, with more than 1,500 customers in over 100 countries and a UK office. It positions itself as one platform for planning, close, consolidation and reporting, with a separate Planful for Marketing product and an AI suite sold as Analyst, Planner, Signals and Projections.

Both are structured finance tools first. If your plan is a chart of accounts with departments, cost centres and projects, either will be live faster than an engine modelled from a blank cube. Workday’s 30 day free trial lets you test the Excel add in against your own trial balance before anyone signs.

Vena and Jedox: planning that still looks like Excel

Vena, from Toronto, passed 2,000 customers in September 2025 and sells itself as Excel native: the templates budget holders fill in are Excel workbooks governed by a central database, workflow and version control, with Power BI embedded for reporting and a Copilot for Microsoft Teams. Vena names native connectors for Microsoft Dynamics, NetSuite, SAP, Oracle, Salesforce, Workday and Microsoft Fabric, and its pricing page offers discounts to not for profits and to Dynamics 365 Business Central users. Two plans are sold, Professional and Complete; the second adds Vena Insights, premium support, a sandbox and managed services, and export APIs cost extra on both.

Jedox was founded in 2002 by Kristian Raue in Freiburg, Germany, and has been majority owned by Insight Partners since early 2021 after a funding round of more than 100 million US dollars. The product is an in memory multidimensional database used through Excel, a web client and mobile, with Jedox AIssisted Planning for forecasting. Packages are Business, Professional and Professional Plus, priced as a monthly fee per named user billed annually across three user types: Full User, Planner and Viewer. Connectors to your ERP, CRM or BI system are an add on at the Business level.

The Excel approach wins adoption and loses control. Budget holders need no training and finance keeps its formulas, but the model can grow into things nobody specified. The discipline has to come from the central data model and the administrators you keep, so budget for them.

Board and Anaplan: modelling platforms for complex businesses

Board International is headquartered in Chiasso, Switzerland, and Boston, has been majority owned by Nordic Capital since 2019 and serves more than 2,000 organisations in over 100 countries. The finance set covers FP&A, cash flow forecasting, capital planning, long term planning and financial close, consolidation and reporting, but Board’s real distinction is the operational side: sales and operations planning, demand and supply planning, and a retail suite for merchandise financial planning, open to buy and WSSI, allocation and range planning. An Office add in and an SAP connector are priced as separate add ons.

Anaplan was founded in Yorkshire in 2006, is now headquartered in Miami and has been owned by Thoma Bravo since June 2022, when the take private completed at about 10.4 billion US dollars. Its Hyperblock engine is a patented in memory calculation layer built for very large connected models, and its integration tooling, Anaplan Connect, CloudWorks, Data Orchestrator and the Integration API, is designed for IT led estates.

These two are the right answer when the finance plan is a fraction of what needs planning: a manufacturer whose budget is driven by a demand plan or a retailer planning ranges and stock. They are the wrong answer for a 40 entity services group that wants a better budget by next quarter, because you will build the finance model from scratch and pay for modelling capability you will not use. The over bought platform with two trained administrators is a pattern I see often; vendor selection is where it is avoided.

How each connects to the ERP and the general ledger

A planning tool is only as good as its actuals, so the integration method is a buying criterion, not a technical footnote. Workday Adaptive Planning’s integration framework offers automated loaders that run scheduled or on demand against prebuilt data sources; its datasheet names Oracle, SAP, NetSuite, Sage Intacct, Microsoft Dynamics, Salesforce, Deltek Vision, Epicor, Sage, Plex and Multiview, plus scripted loaders, an on premise agent and Excel or CSV loads.

Planful lists direct connectors for SAP, NetSuite, Oracle, Microsoft Dynamics 365, QuickBooks, Acumatica and Sage Intacct, plus Workday and other HR systems, Salesforce, HubSpot, Snowflake and Power BI. Loads run on Data Load Rules you schedule, with field mapping and validation before data reaches the model, and its NetSuite ODBC connector queries NetSuite directly through SuiteAnalytics Connect for ledger, transaction and external source data. Vena’s import APIs are included in both plans and export APIs cost extra. Jedox treats connectors as an add on. Board sells its SAP connector separately.

Whatever the tool, the hard work is yours: a clean chart of accounts, consistent dimension codes across entities, a mapping table that finance owns, and a decision on whether budgets flow back into the ERP or stay in the planning tool. Those are the same decisions as any ERP integration, and when the ledger itself is changing, the planning tool’s history load belongs in the data migration plan rather than an afterthought.

What they cost, and the effort to get live

None of the six publishes a UK list price, so there are no pounds figures to give you. Workday’s pricing page marks both Adaptive Planning and the Close and Consolidation package as pricing varies, with quotes through Workday or as a private offer on AWS Marketplace. Planful asks you to book a demo, Vena names its Professional and Complete plans but prices neither, and Board and Anaplan quote per engagement. Jedox is the most open about the mechanism, a monthly fee per named user billed annually across Full User, Planner and Viewer, without publishing the numbers.

What drives the quote, in every case, is the count and type of users, the modules (consolidation is almost always extra), the connectors, the number of entities and currencies, and the support tier. Expect a one year minimum, annual payment in advance, an implementation fee from the vendor or a partner, and a renewal uplift clause worth negotiating out before signature.

On effort, vendor claims are useful mainly as lower bounds. Vena quotes six to eight weeks to first value, Jedox cites a customer live three months from signature. A single entity budget on a structured tool can be live within a quarter if the ledger is clean; a multi entity model with consolidation, workforce planning and three source systems is a two to three quarter programme with a named business owner. Having implemented and delivered most of the ledgers these tools sit on, Oracle, Microsoft Dynamics, NetSuite, Sage, SAP S/4HANA, Unit4 and Access, I can tell you the planning tool is never late because of the planning tool.

Who suits which, and the questions to ask before buying

Workday Adaptive Planning suits a finance team that wants a proven structured model, a wide connector set and a route to consolidation, and pairs naturally with Workday Financials; our Workday Financials page covers that. Planful suits a group with a hard close and consolidation problem alongside budgeting, particularly on NetSuite or Dynamics 365. Vena suits organisations whose budget holders will only ever work in Excel, including charities and Business Central users. Jedox suits European mid market groups that want Excel and web together with a per user price they can forecast. Board suits retailers and manufacturers whose finance plan hangs off a demand or merchandise plan. Anaplan suits large enterprises with an integration team and planning needs well beyond finance.

Ask every shortlisted vendor these questions in writing. Which connector will load our ledger, who built it, and is it included? How are actuals mapped to planning accounts, and who maintains the map? Is consolidation in the price? What counts as a user, and what does a budget holder who enters numbers twice a year cost? Where is the data hosted and can we choose the region? Who implements, and what is their fixed fee for our entity count? What do we export, and in what format, if we leave?

PEF’s practitioners have led and analysed the choices finance teams face before, during and after planning tool and ledger implementations, and we hold no reseller, referral or alliance agreement with any of the six vendors here. Fees are set out plainly on our pricing page.

Related reading: Workday Financials consultancy, ERP integration, Data migration consultancy, ERP vs accounting software, ERP accounting explained, NetSuite vs Sage Intacct.

Common questions

How much does Workday Adaptive Planning cost?

Workday does not publish a price. Its pricing page lists Workday Adaptive Planning and the Close and Consolidation package as pricing varies, with quotes requested directly or through a private offer on AWS Marketplace, and a free 30 day trial. The quote is driven by user numbers and types, whether consolidation is included, connectors and support tier, on an annual subscription paid in advance.

Which FP&A software works inside Excel?

Vena and Jedox keep Excel as the main interface, with governed templates connected to a central database and workflow. Workday Adaptive Planning offers OfficeConnect for Excel, Word and PowerPoint reporting over a web model, Planful connects Microsoft 365 files through Spotlight, Anaplan has an Excel add in and Board sells an Office add in. The difference is whether Excel is where budget holders plan or only where finance reports.

Do I need FP&A software if my ERP already has budgeting?

Not always. If you have one entity, a stable structure and a handful of budget holders, the ERP’s budget module and a disciplined spreadsheet may do. The case for a planning tool arrives with multiple entities or currencies, driver based forecasting, workforce planning, frequent reforecasts, many contributors needing workflow and approvals, or a consolidation that takes a week each month.

How long does an FP&A software implementation take?

Vendor claims range from Vena’s six to eight weeks to first value to a Jedox customer live three months from signature. In practice a single entity budget on a structured tool can be live within a quarter if the ledger and dimensions are clean, while a multi entity model with consolidation, workforce planning and several source systems is a two to three quarter programme with a named finance owner.

Can FP&A software consolidate multiple entities?

Most of the six can, usually as a separately priced module. Workday sells a Close and Consolidation package alongside Adaptive Planning, Planful includes financial close and consolidation in its platform, Vena has an Excel based Financial Consolidation product, Board offers financial close, consolidation and reporting, and Jedox sells a consolidation bundle. Check intercompany eliminations, currency translation and audit trail in the demo on your own entity structure.

Shortlisting planning tools for next year’s budget? Tell me your ERP, entity count and who builds the budget today, and I will say which three to see and what to ask them.

Book a confidential conversation

PEF TRACK RECORD£13bnLargestprogramme led5Continentsdelivered across19 yrsSystems delivery£25mLargestsingle saving

ERP advice from PEF

Independent, client side help across ERP implementation: vendor selection, project management, testing and go live, health checks and programme recovery, on SAP, Oracle, NetSuite, Dynamics 365, Sage, IFS, Odoo, Epicor, Infor and more. Fees are shown plainly on our pricing page.

CF

Written by Christopher Fagan

Managing Partner, PEF Consulting Partners

Christopher has led systems and transformation delivery for 19 years, including the National Grid separation, the £9bn Energy Bills Support Scheme and the BP Pulse EV charging rollout.