Buyer’s guide
HMRC lists well over a hundred recognised payroll products, and the right one for a ten person firm is the wrong one for a 5,000 person employer. Here is how I compare the payroll software UK businesses actually buy, with published prices checked in November 2026.
By Christopher Fagan, Managing Partner, PEF Consulting Partners
Delivered for and alongside
















In this article
Start on GOV.UK. HMRC publishes a list of payroll software it recognises, updated on 16 October 2026, and says plainly that it does not recommend one product over another and is not responsible for problems with software you buy. Recognition means the product has been tested to report PAYE online through Real Time Information. It says nothing about pensions handling, support, pricing or whether the product will still exist next tax year.
The list has two parts. The free list is for employers with fewer than 10 employees and includes HMRC’s own Basic PAYE Tools alongside Primo Payroll, FreePayroll, Enrolpay Small Payroll, RTI Lite, 1 A Simple Payroll and Stansoft. The paid list runs from Sage, Xero, Intuit’s QuickBooks, Bright Software’s BrightPay, Moneysoft’s Payroll Manager and FreeAgent at the small end, through IRIS (Staffology, Cascade, Payrite), Cintra, Moorepay, Cezanne HR, Employment Hero and HiBob, to MHR’s iTrent and People First, Zellis HCM Cloud, ADP iHCM, Dayforce Payroll, Workday, Oracle Fusion Cloud HCM and SAP Payroll.
So treat recognition as a filter, not a recommendation. Everything below passes it. The decisions that matter are size, who runs the payroll, how pensions and statutory pay are handled, and when you switch.
Sage Payroll sells three plans for up to five employees at £10, £20 and £30 a month excluding VAT (Essentials, Standard and Premium), with per head charges above five that fall from £2, £4 and £6 for the sixth to tenth employee to £1, £3 and £5 from the 26th, and a ceiling of 150 employees. Essentials covers RTI, auto enrolment, payslip and P60 self service and basic HR; Standard adds timesheets, an onboarding portal and leave management; Premium adds shift planning and expenses. Sage was advertising 90 per cent off for six months when I checked.
Xero bundles payroll into its accounting plans: Grow at £39 a month includes payroll for one person, Comprehensive at £55 for five and Ultimate at £70 for ten, while Ignite at £18 takes payroll as an add on. Extra people cost £1.50 a month on most plans.
QuickBooks sells payroll only as an add on to a QuickBooks Online subscription, in Core, Premium and Elite tiers. Its UK site loads prices live, so check them on the day; third party guides in 2026 quoted base fees of £5, £10 and £15 a month plus a per employee charge. NEST connects on every tier, Smart Pension on Premium and Elite only.
FreeAgent includes payroll in its limited company plan at £33 a month, or £19 for sole traders not on the cash basis, and is free to NatWest, Royal Bank of Scotland and Ulster Bank business account holders and to qualifying Mettle customers.
BrightPay is cloud only for 2026/27; BrightPay for Windows was discontinued after 5 April 2026. Pricing comes from a calculator based on your highest number of employers and employees, billed monthly in arrears by Direct Debit or annually at a discount. Moneysoft Payroll Manager still publishes flat annual prices: £95 for one employer with up to 20 employees, £190 for up to 100 and £285 for up to 250.
Above 50 people the published price disappears and the questions change: multiple PAYE references, salary sacrifice, attachments of earnings, term time and zero hours contracts, and a ledger that has to reconcile.
Zellis is the UK incumbent. It says it pays one in seven employees in the UK and Ireland, 4.6 million people a month, across ZellisONE Pay, HR, WFM and Talent, with Managed Pay for those who want the processing done for them. MHR sells iTrent and People First, both on HMRC’s list. Moorepay, a Zellis subsidiary based in Swinton, serves smaller employers with HR and payroll software, outsourcing and bureau software plus add ons for time and attendance and expenses. ADP organises itself by size, 1 to 199, 200 to 999 and 1,000 plus, with iHCM for UK employers and Global Payroll for multi country, and is BACS approved. Cintra, based in Newcastle upon Tyne, sells payroll software, bureau software and outsourcing. IRIS owns a stable that includes Staffology and Cascade.
Employment Hero is the exception on price. It publishes Free Payroll at £0, Core Payroll at £4 and Managed Payroll at £14 per employee a month, each with a ten user minimum, and charges extras such as P11D submissions at £7.50 and CIS at £1.70 per subcontractor.
At this tier I weigh a vendor’s payroll heritage above its HR screens. A system that started as payroll and grew HR tends to get gross to net right; a system that started as HR and bolted payroll on needs a harder parallel run.
For large or multi country employers the question is whether payroll sits inside the HCM suite. HMRC’s list includes Workday, Dayforce Payroll from Dayforce EMEA, Oracle’s Fusion Cloud HCM and SAP Payroll, so each of the big suites can pay UK staff natively. The explainers on Dayforce and Workday HCM set out what that involves.
The case for the suite: one employee record, one set of absence data feeding statutory pay, one security model and a payroll journal that lands in the same vendor’s ledger. The case against: UK payroll is a specialist discipline with a tax year, statutory rates and pension rules that change every April, and a global suite’s UK localisation is only as good as its UK customer base and release cadence. Specialists such as Zellis exist because a large part of the market still prefers payroll depth to suite elegance.
Neither answer is wrong. What is wrong is letting the HR selection decide payroll by default. Decide payroll on its own merits, then choose the HR system that fits around it.
Outsourcing does not move the liability. HMRC’s deadlines, the Full Payment Submission no later than payday and the Employer Payment Summary by the 19th of the next tax month, remain yours, as does the pension declaration of compliance. What a bureau or managed service moves is the processing, the software licence and the problem of keeping payroll knowledge in a team of one.
The published example is Employment Hero’s Managed Payroll at £14 per employee a month, which covers managed pay runs, HMRC reporting, RTI and pension enrolment. Zellis says £17bn a year passes through its Managed Services; Moorepay, ADP and Cintra all sell outsourced processing without publishing prices.
Choose a bureau when payroll knowledge is thin, headcount is stable and you can live with the bureau’s calendar. Choose software when you have frequent changes, complex pay rules or want the data inside your own systems. Either way, keep the controls in house: a second person reviews starters and leavers, the gross to net movement is explained each period and the BACS file is approved by someone who did not prepare it.
Every product above has to assess workers against the £10,000 automatic enrolment trigger, calculate 8 per cent of qualifying earnings (£6,240 to £50,270 a year) with the employer paying at least 3 per cent, and send contribution files to the provider; the thresholds are unchanged for 2026/27. The useful differences are in the connectors: Employment Hero includes PensionSync, QuickBooks connects to NEST on every tier and Smart Pension on its upper tiers, and the enterprise products build the file for whichever scheme you run.
Statutory pay changed in April 2026. Sick pay is now due from the first full day off sick, at £123.25 a week or 80 per cent of the employee’s average weekly earnings, whichever is lower, with no lower earnings limit test, so your software must calculate a percentage based SSP for low earners. The parental rates moved to £194.32. From 6 April 2027 cars, fuel, vans and medical benefits must be payrolled with Class 1A National Insurance paid monthly, which rules out any product that cannot payroll benefits.
On timing: switch at 6 April if you can, after the final submission for the old year and well before P60s on 31 May. A mid year move means loading every year to date figure and keeping payroll IDs consistent, or flagging the change on the FPS so HMRC does not create duplicate employments. Allow two parallel runs whichever date you pick. Our payroll implementation page covers that in detail.
Under ten employees with simple pay: Basic PAYE Tools is free but bare, so most owners are better served by the payroll inside the accounting package they already use. Under 50: Sage, Xero or QuickBooks if you want one supplier, BrightPay or Moneysoft if you want a payroll specialist at a known price. From 50 to a few thousand: shortlist Zellis, iTrent, Moorepay, ADP and Cintra, decide bureau against software first, and buy the HR system second. Enterprise: decide whether UK payroll belongs in the suite before you sign the HCM contract, not after.
Whatever the size, insist on three things in the contract: an exit with your data in a usable format, a named approach to each April’s statutory changes, and a parallel run before the first live payday. I have seen more payroll migrations go wrong on the third than on the choice of product.
Related reading: HR software for UK organisations compared, Payroll implementation and migration assurance, Zellis explained, iTrent explained, Dayforce explained, ERP versus accounting software.
HMRC publishes a list on GOV.UK, last updated in October 2026, split into free products for employers with fewer than 10 employees, including HMRC’s own Basic PAYE Tools, and paid products from Sage, Xero, QuickBooks, BrightPay, Moneysoft and FreeAgent through to Zellis, iTrent, ADP, Dayforce, Workday, Oracle and SAP. Recognition means the software can report PAYE online; HMRC does not recommend any product.
On published prices in November 2026, Moneysoft Payroll Manager at £95 a year for one employer with up to 20 employees, Sage Payroll Essentials at £10 a month for up to five employees, and Employment Hero’s Free Payroll tier at £0 with a ten user minimum are the lowest. FreeAgent includes payroll and is free with some business bank accounts. Cheapest is rarely the point; the cost of a wrong payday is.
Yes, if you have fewer than 10 employees. HMRC’s Basic PAYE Tools is free and reports PAYE in real time, and HMRC lists other free products such as Primo Payroll, FreePayroll and RTI Lite. Employment Hero offers a free payroll tier for ten or more users, and FreeAgent is free to NatWest, Royal Bank of Scotland, Ulster Bank and qualifying Mettle customers. Free tools are bare: budget your own time.
Outsource when payroll knowledge sits with one person, headcount is steady and you can work to the bureau’s calendar. Run it yourself when pay rules are complex, changes are frequent or you want the data in your own systems. Liability for HMRC deadlines and the pension declaration stays with you either way, so keep a second pair of eyes on starters, leavers and the BACS file.
The first pay period after 6 April, once the final submissions for the old year are in and before P60s are due on 31 May. Year to date figures start from zero and the new product loads the new rates once. A mid year switch is possible if every year to date figure and payroll ID is carried over exactly, so HMRC does not create duplicate employments.
Switching payroll software? An independent look at your shortlist, your cut over date and your parallel run plan costs less than one wrong payday.
Book a confidential conversation
Independent, client side help on the systems around ERP and CRM: LIMS selection, MES selection, eQMS selection, Computer system validation, HRIS selection and implementation, Payroll implementation, Workday HCM, SAP SuccessFactors, Oracle HCM, Procurement software selection, EAM software selection, WMS selection, Power BI consultancy, and ERP implementation itself. For our fees see pricing.
Written by Christopher Fagan
Managing Partner, PEF Consulting Partners
Christopher has led systems and transformation delivery for 19 years, including the National Grid separation, the £9bn Energy Bills Support Scheme and the BP Pulse EV charging rollout.
Where next