Explainer

ERP vs accounting software: what each covers and when to move

ERP vs accounting software is not a technical distinction. It is a question of how much of the business the system has to run. Here is where the line sits, how to tell when you have crossed it, and what to do about it.

By Christopher Fagan, Managing Partner, PEF Consulting Partners

19 yrssenior systems delivery
7finance platforms delivered
39 daysearly on an Oracle to Dynamics migration
0licences or commissions

Delivered for and alongside

ShellBPCapitaBaringaOfgemSmart DCCInsightsFlui TechnologiesExxonMobilVodafoneConstellation SoftwareDeloittePwCEYNational GridElexon

What accounting software does, and what ERP adds

Accounting software keeps the books. Xero, QuickBooks, Sage 50 and FreeAgent record sales and purchase invoices, pull in bank transactions, reconcile them, run the VAT return and file it with HMRC under Making Tax Digital. For a business with a handful of staff and one legal entity that is all it needs, and the vendors price accordingly: Xero’s Ignite plan is £18 a month and FreeAgent’s limited company plan £33 a month, both before VAT.

ERP runs the business and produces the accounting as a by product. A sales order reserves stock, drives a pick and a despatch, raises the invoice and recognises the revenue. A purchase order commits spend, receives goods, matches the supplier invoice and updates landed cost. A production order consumes materials and books labour. The ledger entries fall out of the operational transaction instead of being typed in afterwards. Around that core sit the things accounting packages lack: several legal entities with intercompany and consolidation, approval workflows with an audit trail, dimensions for reporting by project or site, and one data model that the warehouse, the shop floor and finance all share.

So the line between the two is reach, not features. If finance is the only function living in the system, you have accounting software, however many add ons surround it. If operations post to the ledger through their own work, you have ERP. Our what is ERP explainer walks through the modules themselves.

Signs you have outgrown Xero, QuickBooks, Sage 50 or FreeAgent

The vendors tell you some of the limits themselves, in their plan tables.

  • QuickBooks Online in the UK caps users at one on Simple Start, three on Essentials, five on Plus and 25 on Advanced. If people share logins or queue to post, you have hit the wall.
  • Xero’s Ignite plan allows 20 invoices and 10 bills a month, multi currency is only on Comprehensive and Ultimate, and expenses and projects are limited by active user on each plan.
  • FreeAgent is priced by entity type, sole trader, partnership or limited company, and is built for exactly that: one small entity at a time.
  • Sage 50 charges for extra users on top of the plan price.

The more telling signs are in the business, not the price list.

  • Stock levels, job costs or project margins live in spreadsheets because the accounting package only knows about invoices.
  • Group consolidation, intercompany recharges or a second currency are done by hand each month.
  • Three or more systems hold the same customers and products, and someone re keys between them.
  • Month end takes two weeks because operational data arrives late and in the wrong shape.
  • Auditors, lenders or a buyer in due diligence ask for approval controls and an audit trail you cannot produce.
  • Revenue recognition, landed costs, serial or batch tracking or warranty obligations need rules the package cannot hold.

Any one of these is manageable. Three or more means you are already running an ERP, badly, in spreadsheets.

The middle ground: Sage Intacct, Business Central, NetSuite and Odoo

Between a £33 a month accounting package and a six figure SAP or Oracle programme sits a crowded middle, and it is where most UK firms making this move should look.

Sage Intacct is finance first. Sage’s UK price starts from £1,200 a month before VAT, including three full users and a ten pack of employee licences, with modules as add ons and the quote moving with entities and user roles. It suits groups where finance wants multi entity consolidation and dimensional reporting without buying an operations suite. See our Sage Intacct pricing guide.

Business Central is the Microsoft route. Essentials at £61.50 per user per month covers finance, sales, supply chain planning, projects and warehouse; Premium at £84.60 adds manufacturing and service order management; Team Members cost £6.20. It is bought and implemented through partners. Our Business Central pricing guide has the detail.

NetSuite is the quote only option: an annual licence of core platform, optional modules and users, plus a one time implementation fee, built around OneWorld for multi subsidiary groups. The NetSuite pricing guide explains what a quote contains.

Odoo publishes per user prices and covers an unusually wide set of apps, from accounting and inventory to manufacturing, ecommerce, point of sale and HR, with a free single app tier. It appeals to firms that want breadth at a low licence cost and are prepared to own the configuration.

How to read the four: Intacct if the problem is finance in a group, Business Central or Odoo if the problem is operations and finance together, NetSuite if the problem is scale across entities and countries.

The cost and effort gap

Accounting software is bought with a card and set up in an afternoon, often by your accountant. The monthly fee is tens of pounds, there is no implementation project and the only data to migrate is a trial balance and some contacts.

ERP is a programme. The subscription runs to thousands of pounds a year even for a small team, and the licence is usually the smaller part of the total. On top of it come the implementation fee from the partner or vendor, data migration, process design, integration, testing, training and the time of your own finance lead and process owners, who will give a large share of several months to the project. Realistic ranges are in what an ERP implementation costs in the UK, and the phases and durations are in our ERP implementation timeline article.

The effort gap is the one that catches people. Moving from Xero to Business Central or NetSuite is not an upgrade; it is a redesign of how orders, stock, purchasing and approvals work, with the accounting rebuilt underneath. Firms that treat it as a software swap tend to go live with their old spreadsheets still running alongside. Budget the internal time honestly, and decide who owns the design decisions before you pick a product.

Data, integration and what has to move

Three data questions decide most of the pain of the move.

What history comes across. Most firms migrate opening balances, open items and master data, and leave transaction history in the old system or a reporting store. Bringing years of history into a new chart of accounts with new dimensions costs more than it is worth.

How clean the masters are. Customers, suppliers and items in an accounting package are rarely clean enough for an ERP that will drive picking and pricing from them. Deduplication, units of measure, VAT codes and payment terms are the usual work.

What connects. Bank feeds, payroll, ecommerce and CRM all need rewiring. The ERP vendors handle bank feeds differently: NetSuite’s Bank Feeds SuiteApp is free and covers UK banks through Salt Edge with a daily import; Business Central’s own Envestnet Yodlee feed covers only the United States and Canada, so UK banks connect through third party apps; Odoo synchronises through third party providers every twelve hours on an Enterprise subscription. The HMRC connection for Making Tax Digital has to be set up again in the new system, and all three platforms do it slightly differently.

None of this is hard if it is planned. All of it is painful if discovered in the last month before go live. Our data migration consultancy exists for exactly this.

How to decide and what to do first

Do not start with a demo. Start with four pieces of work that cost nothing but time.

  1. Write down the ten processes that hurt. Order to cash, procure to pay, stock, month end, consolidation. Note where the spreadsheet starts in each one. That list is your requirements document.
  2. Count users by type. Who posts transactions, who approves, who only reads. Licence costs turn on this: from £6.20 to £84.60 per user per month in Business Central alone.
  3. Model three years. Subscription, implementation, apps, integration, your own time. Compare it with the cost of staying, including the hires and errors the current setup causes.
  4. Decide the scope. Finance only, which points to Intacct or to staying put a while longer, or finance and operations together, which points to Business Central, NetSuite or Odoo.

Then run a proper selection with a shortlist of three and scripted demonstrations on your own scenarios. Our free ERP readiness assessment is a reasonable first pass.

I have delivered most of the finance systems named here over 19 years, from Sage and Access to NetSuite, Microsoft Dynamics and SAP S/4HANA, and the firms that get this right know why they are moving before they know what to. If you want an independent view, alongside your team or leading the work, our fees are shown plainly on the pricing page.

Related reading: What is ERP?, ERP accounting explained, ERP for small business, Sage 200 vs Sage 50 vs Sage Intacct, ERP implementation timeline, ERP readiness assessment.

Common questions

Is Xero an ERP system?

No. Xero is accounting software: ledger, invoicing, bills, bank reconciliation, VAT and payroll, with no per user licence fees and third party apps available for stock, projects and reporting. It becomes ERP like only by stitching those apps together, each holding its own data. Once stock, jobs or several entities drive the business, a true ERP with one data model is usually cheaper to run than the patchwork.

At what size does a business need ERP rather than accounting software?

Headcount and turnover are poor guides; complexity is the trigger. A £3m manufacturer with stock, bills of materials and two sites may need ERP, while a £20m consultancy with one entity and no stock can run on accounting software and a project tool for years. Look for several entities, physical stock, production, projects with margin tracking or more than 25 system users, which is where QuickBooks Advanced stops.

Can I keep Xero or QuickBooks and add inventory software instead of moving to ERP?

Yes, and for a single entity with simple stock it is often the right call for a few more years. The risk is accumulating three or four connected apps, each holding part of the truth, with integrations to maintain and no shared audit trail. When the connectors break at month end or the stock app and the ledger disagree, the patchwork costs more than it saves.

How much more does ERP cost than accounting software?

A lot more. Xero’s standard plans run from £18 to £70 a month and FreeAgent’s business plans from £19 to £33, before VAT. Business Central starts at £61.50 per user per month, Sage Intacct from £1,200 a month for the base subscription, and NetSuite is quoted. Add an implementation fee, data migration, integration and your own team’s time, and a mid market ERP programme is a five or six figure project rather than a subscription.

What is the difference between Sage 50 and Sage Intacct?

Sage 50 is small business accounting software, priced per plan with extra users at an additional fee. Sage Intacct is Sage’s cloud financial management platform for multi entity groups, priced from £1,200 a month in the UK with three full users and ten employee licences included and modules as add ons. Moving between them is a system implementation, not an upgrade, with a new chart of accounts, dimensions and approval workflows.

Not sure whether you have outgrown your accounting software? Take the readiness assessment or ask us. We will tell you plainly if your current package still has years left in it.

Book a confidential conversation

PEF TRACK RECORD£13bnLargestprogramme led5Continentsdelivered across19 yrsSystems delivery£25mLargestsingle saving

ERP advice from PEF

Independent, client side help across ERP implementation: vendor selection, project management, testing and go live, health checks and programme recovery, on SAP, Oracle, NetSuite, Dynamics 365, Sage, IFS, Odoo, Epicor, Infor and more. Fees are shown plainly on our pricing page.

CF

Written by Christopher Fagan

Managing Partner, PEF Consulting Partners

Christopher has led systems and transformation delivery for 19 years, including the National Grid separation, the £9bn Energy Bills Support Scheme and the BP Pulse EV charging rollout.