Sector guide

CRM for charities: donors, Gift Aid, consent and the platforms that fit

A charity’s CRM has to do three things a commercial one never faces: claim Gift Aid from HMRC without error, prove every contact’s consent, and keep a regular giver for a decade. Here is how I would buy one in 2026, with the prices the vendors published.

By Christopher Fagan, Managing Partner, PEF Consulting Partners

19 yrssenior systems delivery
7finance platforms delivered
39 daysearly on an Oracle to Dynamics migration
22m+assets in the National Grid separation

Delivered for and alongside

ShellBPCapitaBaringaOfgemSmart DCCInsightsFlui TechnologiesExxonMobilVodafoneConstellation SoftwareDeloittePwCEYNational GridElexon

Why a charity CRM is a finance and compliance system first

Ask a commercial sales director what a CRM is for and you get one answer: pipeline. Ask a charity’s director of fundraising and you get five. The same database has to hold a donor who gives £10 a month by Direct Debit, a volunteer who runs the Saturday shop, a trust that funds a three year programme, a corporate supporter, and a beneficiary whose record must be kept apart from all of them. A CRM for charities is a supporter ledger with a fundraising screen on top, and if you buy it as a marketing tool you will spend the next two years bolting the ledger on.

Three things make the sector different and all three are about money and law. Gift Aid turns £1 into £1.25 only if the declaration behind it survives an HMRC inspection. Direct marketing to supporters is governed by UK GDPR, the Privacy and Electronic Communications Regulations and, since November 2025, a rewritten Code of Fundraising Practice. And the money arrives in dozens of shapes: single gifts, regular giving, legacies, grants received, grants made, event income, trading and gifts in kind, each with its own treatment in the accounts.

So the buying brief is not which CRM has the best dashboards. It is: which system claims Gift Aid without error, proves consent for every contact, keeps a regular giver for a decade, and posts clean income to the finance system. Everything below follows from that list. For the general market view, my best CRM UK guide covers the platforms outside the sector.

Gift Aid: the claim is only as good as the declaration record

HMRC’s rules are plain and unforgiving. You can claim 25p for every £1 an individual gives, you must claim within four years of the end of the financial period in which you received the donation, and you must keep a record of each declaration for six years after the most recent donation you claimed on. Claims go through Charities Online, and for more than 1,000 donations in a claim you must use software. The Gift Aid Small Donations Scheme adds a top up on cash and contactless gifts of £30 or less, worth up to £2,000 a tax year, claimed within two years and with records kept for a further two.

Translate that into data. Every gift needs a link to a declaration; the declaration needs a start date, an end date if withdrawn, the donor’s name and home address as they stood at the time, and a flag showing whether the gift was claimed, in which claim, and when HMRC paid. The products built for the sector do this natively. Donorfy includes automatic Gift Aid claiming on every plan. Beacon processes Gift Aid with no fee. Blackbaud announced in October 2025 that UK Raiser’s Edge NXT customers can collect declarations through its donation forms, run automated checks against HMRC rules and submit claims directly from the product.

A general CRM can be configured to do the same, but the configuration is the project, not an afterthought. I delivered the £9bn Energy Bills Support Scheme for Ofgem, BEIS and HMRC, and the habit it left me with is simple: money reclaimed from the public purse needs a trail you could hand over tomorrow morning. Test any shortlisted system with a year of your own untidy declarations before you sign.

Two rule changes landed within months of each other. The Fundraising Regulator’s new Code of Fundraising Practice took effect on 1 November 2025 after a six month transition. It has 14 standards in three sections: all fundraising, working with others, and specific methods. Then the charitable purpose soft opt in arrived. Section 114 of the Data (Use and Access) Act 2025 adds regulation 22(3A) to the Privacy and Electronic Communications Regulations, letting a charity send electronic mail marketing about its charitable purposes without consent, provided three conditions hold: the sole purpose is to further the charity’s purposes, the details were obtained when the person expressed interest in or offered support for those purposes, and a simple free opt out was offered at collection and with every message since. Law firm commentary I read puts commencement at 5 February 2026; the ICO’s own pages still described it as expected when I checked, so confirm the date with your adviser.

The CRM consequence is the one most charities miss. The soft opt in cannot be applied to people whose details you collected before it came into force, so the record must show the date and the route by which every contact’s details arrived. The ICO also recommends separate lists for consent based and soft opt in contacts, an updated privacy notice, and a suppression list for anyone who has objected.

In practice that means a preference centre on the supporter record with a lawful basis, a source, a timestamp and a channel for each permission, plus an objection flag that nothing can override. Donorfy ships a GDPR preference centre on its Starter plan. On Salesforce, Dynamics 365 or HubSpot you build it.

Regular giving, Direct Debit and the whole supporter record

Regular giving is the economics of the sector, and Direct Debit is its plumbing. To collect Direct Debits in your own name you need a Service User Number, which is issued only through sponsorship by a Bacs participant; sponsors look for management expertise, financial reserves to cover indemnity claims under the Direct Debit Guarantee, usually held in a surety bond, and the contractual capacity to indemnify the bank. Smaller charities collect indirectly through a bureau, which owns the SUNs and runs a client money account, or a payments institution collecting under its own name. Beacon takes payments through Stripe, GoCardless and PayPal and charges no platform fee on them. Donorfy connects to Enthuse and JustGiving for online giving. Whichever route you take, the CRM must hold the mandate reference, the collection schedule, failures and retries, and the Gift Aid link on every instalment.

Then widen the record. The same person is often a donor, an event participant, a volunteer and a member, and the moment those live in four systems you lose the ability to see that your most reliable volunteer has never been thanked for her giving. Access describes its Charity CRM, the upgraded version of thankQ, as managing donors, beneficiaries and volunteers in one record, and that is the right shape whichever vendor you pick. Grants need both directions: funders you report to, with restricted fund tags that reach the finance system, and, for grant making charities, the awards you make. Salesforce includes its grantmaking suite in the Nonprofit Cloud Max editions and prices it separately below that.

The platforms that fit, with the prices I checked

Prices are as published for the UK in November 2026.

  • Salesforce Nonprofit Cloud. Any eligible nonprofit receives 10 Nonprofit Cloud Core licences at no cost, with further licences discounted: Core £50, Advanced £100 and Sales Max or Service Max £228 per user per month, billed annually on an annual contract. Gift Aid handling and the implementer are where the real cost sits.
  • Microsoft Dynamics 365. Discounted Sales Enterprise and Customer Service licences for eligible nonprofits; the UK nonprofit page quoted only US dollar prices, 23.80 a user a month for Sales Enterprise. The catch: Microsoft’s own Fundraising and Engagement solution is being retired, with support ending on 31 December 2026, so a Dynamics charity needs a specialist fundraising layer or its own build. Our Dynamics 365 Customer Engagement page covers the platform.
  • Blackbaud Raiser’s Edge NXT. The sector’s long standing enterprise product, now with direct Gift Aid submission in the UK. No list prices are published; budget for a quoted subscription plus implementation.
  • Access Charity CRM and Donorfy. Both sit with The Access Group. Access Charity CRM is thankQ renamed and upgraded, quote only, and Access says it works with over 2,000 fundraising organisations. Donorfy publishes Starter from £40, Professional from £71 and Enterprise from £308 a month plus VAT, with unlimited users on Starter and a 30 day trial.
  • Beacon. Starter £37 a month, or £33.50 paid annually, for up to 2,000 contacts and three users; Standard £127 or £114 for up to 50,000 contacts and ten users; Premium £325 or £292 for up to 100,000 contacts; Ultimate on quote. Implementation is done by Beacon’s partners and is not in the price.
  • HubSpot. Its nonprofit programme, 40 per cent off new Professional and Enterprise products, is open only to organisations located and registered as nonprofits in North America, Australia or New Zealand, so a UK charity pays list price unless it negotiates, and nothing on HubSpot’s UK pricing pages mentions Gift Aid.

How to choose: a method that fits a charity’s budget

A charity’s selection should take weeks, not a year, and it should be run by the people who will live in the system. The method I use has six steps.

  1. Write down the income mix for the last two years by type and channel, the number of live regular givers, and the volume of Gift Aid claimed. That decides whether you are a Beacon or Donorfy sized organisation or a Raiser’s Edge, Salesforce or Dynamics one.
  2. Hand each shortlisted vendor a real export, anonymised, including the awkward declarations and the lapsed Direct Debits, and watch them claim Gift Aid from it in the demo.
  3. Agree the consent model first: which lawful basis for which channel, how soft opt in contacts are kept apart from consented ones, and where the objection flag lives.
  4. Map the finance join. Restricted and unrestricted income, fund codes and the posting of each gift to the ledger are where sector systems earn their keep and where general ones need building. Our CRM integration page sets out how we do that.
  5. Price the whole thing: subscription, implementation, data migration, payment processing and the first year of support. The free seats and discounts are real, but the implementation is usually the larger number.
  6. Decide who assures the delivery. PEF’s consultants have steered and scrutinised the decisions taken before, during and after migrations onto these platforms, and we take nothing from any vendor. Bring us in as independent assurance beside your chosen implementer or ask us to lead the work; our fees are set out plainly on the pricing page, and the starting point is our CRM implementation consultancy page.

Related reading: CRM for membership organisations, The best CRM UK businesses can buy in 2026, What a CRM costs in the UK, Independent CRM consultants, CRM migration consultancy, HubSpot vs Salesforce.

Common questions

What is the best CRM for a small charity in the UK?

For a small charity the practical choice in November 2026 is between Beacon and Donorfy, both priced from under £40 a month, both built around Gift Aid, Direct Debit and consent, with Donorfy giving unlimited users on its Starter plan and Beacon capping Starter at three. Salesforce’s ten free Nonprofit Cloud licences are tempting, but the implementation and Gift Aid configuration usually cost more than a year of either.

Can a charity CRM claim Gift Aid directly from HMRC?

Some can. Blackbaud announced direct submission of Gift Aid claims from Raiser’s Edge NXT for UK customers in October 2025, and Donorfy includes automatic Gift Aid claiming on all plans. Others produce the HMRC schedule for you to upload through Charities Online. Whatever the route, HMRC requires software for claims of more than 1,000 donations and declaration records kept for six years after the last claimed gift.

Does Salesforce give charities free licences in the UK?

Yes. Salesforce’s UK Nonprofit Cloud pricing page states that any eligible nonprofit receives ten Nonprofit Cloud Core licences at no cost, with further licences at discounted nonprofit prices: Core £50, Advanced £100 and the Max editions £228 per user per month billed annually. Eligibility is checked, an annual contract is required and implementation is not included, so budget for an implementer as well.

Do UK charities get the HubSpot nonprofit discount?

Not under the published programme. HubSpot’s nonprofit page offers 40 per cent off new Professional or Enterprise products, but only to organisations located and registered as nonprofits in North America, Australia or New Zealand, on an annual contract, and says other regions will be added later. A UK charity can still ask for a discount in negotiation, but should plan on list prices until HubSpot extends the programme.

What is the charitable purpose soft opt in and does our CRM need to change?

It is a change made by the Data (Use and Access) Act 2025 to the Privacy and Electronic Communications Regulations that lets charities email or text people who expressed interest or offered support, without consent, provided an opt out was offered at collection and in every message. It does not cover people whose details were collected before it started, so your CRM must record when and how each contact’s details were obtained and keep those lists separate.

What happens to charities using Microsoft Fundraising and Engagement?

Microsoft is retiring Fundraising and Engagement, with support ending on 31 December 2026. Charities on it will still have Dynamics 365 underneath, but they need a replacement fundraising layer, either a specialist product built on Dynamics or their own configuration, and should plan the migration of gifts, declarations and Direct Debit mandates now rather than in the final quarter of the year.

Need a supporter database your trustees can trust? We help charities choose, implement and recover CRM systems, independent of every vendor, with our fees set out plainly on the pricing page.

Book a confidential conversation

PEF TRACK RECORD£13bnLargestprogramme led5Continentsdelivered across19 yrsSystems delivery£25mLargestsingle saving

CRM advice from PEF

Independent, client side help with CRM selection and strategy, Salesforce, HubSpot, Dynamics 365 Customer Engagement and Zoho CRM, plus CRM integration, CRM migration and a Salesforce and CRM health check. Fees are shown plainly on our pricing page.

CF

Written by Christopher Fagan

Managing Partner, PEF Consulting Partners

Christopher has led systems and transformation delivery for 19 years, including the National Grid separation, the £9bn Energy Bills Support Scheme and the BP Pulse EV charging rollout.