Sector guide
Recruitment is the one industry where the CRM has two customers at once. The candidate and the client sit on the same placement, and the system has to serve both without the compliance trail breaking. Here is how I would buy one in 2026.
By Christopher Fagan, Managing Partner, PEF Consulting Partners
Delivered for and alongside
















In this article
Every other CRM I have specified has one customer on a deal. A recruitment agency has two. The client who pays the fee and the candidate who fills the job both sit on the same placement, and a CRM for recruitment that serves one side well and the other badly produces the result you see in most agencies: consultants live in LinkedIn and email, the database is six months stale, and the only reliable record is the invoice.
The split runs through the whole product category. Firefish packages its plans by workflow: Core for permanent teams, Scale adding contract, Enterprise adding temporary. JobAdder’s entry plan runs a permanent only CRM with a single applicant workflow, and its higher plans add temp and contractor talent pools. Bullhorn’s Starter plan is described as applicant tracking, CV parsing, client management and job posting, with what it calls recruitment CRM arriving at the Pro tier. The vendors are telling you something: perm, contract and temp are different businesses with different data, and the system has to know which one you are on for each job.
So before any demo, write down your mix. A perm boutique needs a candidate relationship database with a light client pipeline. A temp desk needs availability, shifts, timesheets and compliance documents, and the client side is close to a billing relationship. A contract agency needs both plus the off payroll working paperwork on every placement. For the general market, the best CRM UK guide is the companion piece.
Agencies ask me whether they need an ATS or a CRM, and the honest answer is that the question is a legacy of two product categories that have merged. An applicant tracking system is job centred: a vacancy, applications against it, stages from screened to offered. A CRM is relationship centred: a company, the people in it, the conversations over years, and the jobs that fall out of those conversations. Recruitment needs both views of one database, because the candidate you placed in 2022 is the hiring manager who calls you in 2026.
The failure pattern is buying them separately. Business development goes into HubSpot or Salesforce because the sales team likes it, candidates go into a recruitment ATS, and within a year there are two records for the same person, two sets of consents and no single view of margin. If you want the Salesforce platform underneath, Bullhorn sells Recruitment Cloud, which it describes as core ATS functions within Salesforce, with a Front Office edition adding a job leads pipeline, document generation and automation, and a Workforce Edition adding shift scheduling, time capture and timesheet approval. That keeps one data model.
If you buy a recruitment platform, check what its CRM actually contains: company hierarchies, contacts moving between employers, business development activity, terms of business against the client, and a lead feed from job postings. JobAdder lists a Lead Feed in its Essential plan. Bullhorn lists client management from Starter and recruitment CRM from Pro. Recruit CRM sells one product it calls ATS plus CRM, with a hiring manager portal from its lowest tier.
Sourcing plumbing decides whether consultants work in the system or around it. Four connections matter.
Then the data protection question that sits under all of this. Candidate data is personal data under UK GDPR, some of it sensitive, and a sourcing extension that fills your database with people who have never spoken to you creates an obligation on day one. Set a retention rule, record the source and lawful basis on every candidate, and make sure the system can actually delete when the rule says so.
This section should decide the purchase, because the penalties are real and the record keeping is what saves you.
Right to work. Employing someone without the right to work, or without doing the correct checks, carries a civil penalty of up to £60,000 for each illegal worker; knowingly doing so carries up to five years in prison and an unlimited fine. The defence is having made the correct checks. The Home Office republished its employer’s guide on 1 October 2026. The CRM must hold the check type, date, evidence and any follow up date on the candidate, and must stop a placement being confirmed without them.
Agency or employment business. Government guidance separates employment agencies, which introduce work seekers who are then employed and paid by the hirer, from employment businesses, which engage the worker and pay them for temporary work under the hirer’s supervision. A business doing both follows both sets of rules: no fees to work seekers for work finding, a key information document and written terms before work finding begins, and temps paid for every hour worked even where the hirer has not authorised the timesheet.
Agency workers’ rights. After 12 weeks in the same job a temporary agency worker is entitled to the same pay as a permanent colleague doing the same work, paid annual leave and automatic pension enrolment. The system has to count the weeks.
Off payroll working. Where a contractor works through their own company, the client usually determines employment status and should produce a status determination statement with reasons. Where the rules apply, the deemed employer, often the agency paying the contractor’s company, deducts income tax and employee National Insurance and pays employer National Insurance and any apprenticeship levy. Store the statement against the placement, not in email.
Timesheets are where the two sides of the business meet and where the CRM should hand over. The candidate submits hours, the client approves them, the agency pays the worker and invoices the client, and the margin on every placement falls out of the difference. Which system does what is a design decision, not a default.
The platforms draw the line in different places. Bullhorn’s Workforce Edition, on its Salesforce based Recruitment Cloud, covers shift scheduling, time capture, timesheet approval, mobile engagement and rate card management. Vincere lists payment and billing among the extras you add to its £69 per user CRM and ATS. Recruit CRM runs timesheets as a credit consuming feature at 100 credits per active contractor per month. JobAdder’s pricing page does not mention timesheets at all. None of them is a payroll or a ledger, and nor should they be.
So the integration points are fixed: approved timesheets and rate cards out to payroll and invoicing, paid and invoiced status back to the placement, and margin by consultant, client and desk reported from the finance side where the numbers are reconciled. Over 19 years I have implemented most of the finance systems a pay and bill process ends up in, Sage, Microsoft Dynamics and NetSuite among them, and the join between the operational record and the ledger is where every one of those programmes had its hardest week. Agree which system is master for the client, the worker and the rate before anyone configures anything. Our CRM integration page explains how we run that work.
What the vendors published in November 2026.
How to choose: let your perm, contract and temp mix pick the category; run the right to work, agency worker and status determination scenario in every demo with your own documents; price the add ons, because the seat fee is rarely half the bill; and plan the migration of candidate history, consents and documents before you sign, as our CRM migration page sets out. PEF’s consultants have advised on and reviewed the decisions made before, during and after moves onto these platforms, and we sell no software and take no commission. Work with us as independent assurance alongside your implementer or as the team that leads delivery; fees are shown plainly on our pricing page, and our CRM consultants page explains both routes.
Related reading: CRM for professional services, The best CRM UK businesses can buy, HubSpot vs Salesforce, CRM integration consultancy, What a CRM costs in the UK, Salesforce pricing in the UK.
An applicant tracking system is built around jobs: a vacancy, the applicants against it and their stages. A CRM is built around relationships: companies, contacts, candidates and years of conversations. Recruitment needs both views of one database, which is why Bullhorn, Vincere, JobAdder, Firefish and Recruit CRM all sell combined products. Buying them separately creates duplicate candidate records and two consent trails.
In November 2026 Bullhorn’s UK pricing page listed Starter at £80 and Core at £120 per user per month for small agencies, both with free implementation, while Pro, Max, the Front Office plans for larger agencies and the Salesforce based Recruitment Cloud editions were quote only. Add ons such as onboarding, automation, messaging and analytics are priced separately, so the seat fee is only part of the bill.
The CRM should record and enforce them rather than perform them. The check itself follows the Home Office employer’s guide, updated 1 October 2026, and the penalty for getting it wrong is up to £60,000 per illegal worker. Configure the system to hold the check type, date, evidence and follow up date, and to block a placement from being confirmed until they are present.
Yes, for contract placements. Under the off payroll working rules the client determines status and issues a status determination statement, and the deemed employer, often the agency paying the contractor’s company, deducts income tax and employee National Insurance. Store the statement, the outcome and the date against each placement, so that payroll, invoicing and any HMRC enquiry can see them without a search through email.
Salesforce can be, through Bullhorn’s Recruitment Cloud, which runs core ATS functions inside Salesforce, or a specialist build. HubSpot’s published Sales Hub plans have no recruitment edition, so it suits the client side business development of an agency that keeps candidates in a separate ATS. That is workable only if you accept two systems and design the integration between them deliberately.
Want one record from first call to final invoice? We help agencies choose and deliver recruitment CRM and ATS platforms independently of every vendor, with our fees shown plainly on the pricing page.
Book a confidential conversation
Independent, client side help with CRM selection and strategy, Salesforce, HubSpot, Dynamics 365 Customer Engagement and Zoho CRM, plus CRM integration, CRM migration and a Salesforce and CRM health check. Fees are shown plainly on our pricing page.
Written by Christopher Fagan
Managing Partner, PEF Consulting Partners
Christopher has led systems and transformation delivery for 19 years, including the National Grid separation, the £9bn Energy Bills Support Scheme and the BP Pulse EV charging rollout.
Where next